|
|
Post by Seger on Jan 27, 2020 11:35:17 GMT
I list the 11 generals that may be added. I already have hipper and vorbeck. I am still looking for the other one, so if one has been found, take a picture and tell me what his highest rank is (king, emperor etc.) There are only 11 choices of generals. I know that’s why I want to compare them |
|
|
|
Post by Navia Lanoira on Jan 27, 2020 12:08:49 GMT
There are only 11 choices of generals. I know that’s why I want to compare them Yes, what, what do you mean by need the other one? |
|
|
|
Post by Seger on Jan 27, 2020 12:14:21 GMT
I know that’s why I want to compare them Yes, what, what do you mean by need the other one? Typo it should be the other ones, the generals beside Vorbeck and hipper |
|
|
|
Post by Harry Lillis "Bing" Crosby Jr on Jan 27, 2020 14:15:20 GMT
wait Seger, they are out? for ios again??? rip android though we have yet to even get the multiplayer update... |
|
|
|
Post by Seger on Jan 27, 2020 14:19:36 GMT
wait Seger , they are out? for ios again??? rip android though we have yet to even get the multiplayer update... No they aren't but the generals you can vote on are already in the game, you can find them in campaigns you just cant buy them. |
|
|
|
Post by Seger on Jan 27, 2020 15:37:29 GMT
Btw I reworked the concept of this post
|
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Jan 27, 2020 15:39:41 GMT
Btw I reworked the concept of this post Thank you! I was having some “Should I get this guy or not” thoughts. |
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Jan 27, 2020 15:41:53 GMT
method: battle ability + infantry ability = TA (total ability) wich skills a general has aren't taken into account because of books. This is the best possible from of every general. For the cost comparison of books, the skills must meet two things: 1. They are all above average according to the list of Alexyx. 2. The skills are not bad when you combine them, think of attacking and defensive skills and more than one terrain skill (forest and mountains are an exception because they stack). So it doesn't matter to me whether the skills are the best as long as they are good. I think it is a waste of books, for example, to change forest to plain. infantry requiredgoodokay as a cheap alternativeonly if this is your main unit typebadterribleInfantry 1. E.Lee: TA=155 defense=45% skills: 5 medals:780 books:15 change:battle array and tunnel2. Haig: TA=150 defense=42% skills:5 medals=650 books=5 change:street fighting3: Boroevic: TA=148 defense=42% skills: 5 medals=650 books=5 change:battle array4: Bismarck TA=141 defense=45% skills: 4 medals=550 books=5-15 change:counterattack or change ambush and tactic master and make him defensive. 5: Macmahon TA=122 defense=38% skills: 5 medals=520 books=15 change:cover and counter attack6: Nicholas I TA=138 defense=45% skills: 4 medals=0 books=5 change:tunnel7: Micis TA=114 defense=38% skills: 5 medals=530 books=15 change:battle array and cover8: Garibaldi TA=146 defense=45% skills: 3 medals=540 books=0 change:-Cavarly 1. Jackson: TA=157 defense=45% skills=5 medals=0 books=5 change:station2. Sidney: TA=148 defense=42% skills=5 medals=620 books=5 change: counter attack3. Stepanovic: TA=149 defense=38% skills=5 medals=730 books=15 change:maneuver and cover4. Joffre: TA=148 defense=38% skills=5 medals=540 books=15 change: station and maneuver5. McClellan: TA=131 defense=45% skills=4 medals=550 books=0 change:-6. Moltke the Younger: TA=127 defense=38% skills=5 medals=570 books=5 change: counter attack7. Mackensen: TA=121 defense=38% skills=5 medals=540 books=30 change: mountain fighting, counter attack and maneuver
8. Gough: TA=120 defense=38% skills=5 medals=520 books=30 change: sailor, counter attack and maneuverArtilery Kemal is better than dimitriev because his defense is much better and because dimitriev can only become a duke and therefore his skills are only lv4. 1. Hindenburg: TA=164 defense=45% skills=5 2. Ivanov: TA=160 defense=42% skills=5 3. Prince Leopold: TA=147 defense=38% skills=5 4. Hötzendorf: TA=132 defense=38% skills=4 5. Kemal: TA=129 defense=45% skills=4 6. Dimitriev: TA=127 defense=35% skills=5 7. Nicholas II: TA=117 defense=45% skills=4 8. Otto von Below: TA=111 defense=45% skills=4 Navy 1. Beatty: TA=142 defense=38% skills=5 2. Bacon: TA=148 defense=45% skills=4 3. Duke of Aosta: TA=119 defense=38% skills=4 But wait. Is the pool general-wise or skill-wise? Because I would like to disagree with some of the skill changes. |
|
|
|
Post by Seger on Jan 27, 2020 15:47:25 GMT
the poll is for the colors. with the skills I have which you should remove but if you do not agree with that I would like to hear your comments
|
|
|
|
Post by Pietro Badoglio on Jan 27, 2020 15:50:19 GMT
I'd recommend adding a / or : as it looks like you'll need 570 books to to change 5 skills.
nvm, I'm just blind
|
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Jan 27, 2020 15:57:07 GMT
the poll is for the colors. with the skills I have which you should remove but if you do not agree with that I would like to hear your comments Personally, I find Inspiration to be a meh skill. It doesn’t do much other than giving a small boost to your general. Even if you intend to use it as a tool against morale drops, it’s too unreliable. Ambush is a bad skill in my opinion. Chance to dodge is too low to be able to rely on it, even if you only rely a bit on it. There is also the fact that in this game, offense is more important than defense. On admirals, true, you SHOULD put defensive skills like Alert and Escort, but in Infantry, you should favor offense over defense. |
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Jan 27, 2020 16:00:49 GMT
I also think that Alert is not good for Infantry, pointing at Nicholas I. Artillery units and ships are made for crippling cities, destroying forts and destroying enemy ships. They suck at killing Infantry, so I don’t believe they are enough of a concern for you to leave Alert on a Infantry general.
Again, Nicholas I is bad, so you might as well not bother to spend a single book on him.
|
|
|
|
Post by Seger on Jan 27, 2020 16:04:01 GMT
the poll is for the colors. with the skills I have which you should remove but if you do not agree with that I would like to hear your comments Personally, I find Inspiration to be a meh skill. It doesn’t do much other than giving a small boost to your general. Even if you intend to use it as a tool against morale drops, it’s too unreliable. Ambush is a bad skill in my opinion. Chance to dodge is too low to be able to rely on it, even if you only rely a bit on it. There is also the fact that in this game, offense is more important than defense. On admirals, true, you SHOULD put defensive skills like Alert and Escort, but in Infantry, you should favor offense over defense. I agree with you, but if the only other option is to use 15 books to replace inspiration, I wouldn't make it a priority. And I also agree with defense, so I recommend removing it from all cavalry. Only I also think it is useful to have a general who can defend well, but because I realize that more is an opinion than a fact, I write down both options |
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Jan 27, 2020 16:07:35 GMT
If you have leftover books (Not sure if that is a thing, but here we go), you should change critical-chance boosting skills (Formation Master, Riding Master etc) because the chance is too low to make critical hits reliable in my opinion.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Jan 27, 2020 16:10:28 GMT
Personally, I find Inspiration to be a meh skill. It doesn’t do much other than giving a small boost to your general. Even if you intend to use it as a tool against morale drops, it’s too unreliable. Ambush is a bad skill in my opinion. Chance to dodge is too low to be able to rely on it, even if you only rely a bit on it. There is also the fact that in this game, offense is more important than defense. On admirals, true, you SHOULD put defensive skills like Alert and Escort, but in Infantry, you should favor offense over defense. I agree with you, but if the only other option is to use 15 books to replace inspiration, I wouldn't make it a priority. And I also agree with defense, so I recommend removing it from all cavalry. Only I also think it is useful to have a general who can defend well, but because I realize that more is an opinion than a fact, I write down both options True. Just like the critical-chance boosting skills, Inspiration shouldn’t be a priority if the cost is at 15 books (Or more, but at 4 skills or more needing replacement, it’s better to not bother using the general). If you do have leftover books, though, change it. |
|
