|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 11, 2020 21:27:05 GMT
Hello! This is a star wars room where you can talk about anything in stars wars! Battle tatics, generals, movies etc. There are rules though... - No trolling!
- Videos are allowed!
- Make sure it's about star wars!
- Make sure nothing is too inappropriate!
- Have fun!
Now Don't break the justice of my new theard!
|
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 11, 2020 21:41:33 GMT
Does anyone remember the Revenge of the sith screen when those red guards were taken down with ease. They are worse then the b1 battle droids.
|
|
|
|
Post by Darth Nihilus on Jun 11, 2020 22:21:55 GMT
Does anyone remember the Revenge of the sith screen when those red guards were taken down with ease. They are worse then the b1 battle droids. That fight was terribly choreographed lol. Shadiversity, who's a sword-fighting pro, did a frame-by-frame analysis of it. Here's the link, if you want to see some parts, but it's really long. Also, there's like never any flanking strategies in Star Wars. From the Battle of Naboo to whatever Exegol was, every battle has been head-on tilts. The only in-movie sneak attack that was actually purely a sneak attack was the Battle of Coruscant, which is actually one of the best space battles in cinema history. A shame only about 30 minutes of its 5-day length was shown. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 11, 2020 22:26:59 GMT
Does anyone remember the Revenge of the sith screen when those red guards were taken down with ease. They are worse then the b1 battle droids. That fight was terribly choreographed lol. Shadiversity, who's a sword-fighting pro, did a frame-by-frame analysis of it. Here's the link, if you want to see some parts, but it's really long. Also, there's like never any flanking strategies in Star Wars. From the Battle of Naboo to whatever Exegol was, every battle has been head-on tilts. The only in-movie sneak attack that was actually purely a sneak attack was the Battle of Coruscant, which is actually one of the best space battles in cinema history. A shame only about 30 minutes of its 5-day length was shown. I know I remember watching the 2003 star wars. It's Was the best because if it's shear scale of units in the show. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 12, 2020 0:23:14 GMT
Does anyone remember the stormtrooper from the new hope. At the beginning they crushed the rebals. The only reason they didn't kill Luke and the others because it would not look pleasing to the Audience.
|
|
|
|
Post by Darth Nihilus on Jun 12, 2020 14:58:46 GMT
Does anyone remember the stormtrooper from the new hope. At the beginning they crushed the rebals. The only reason they didn't kill Luke and the others because it would not look pleasing to the Audience. Actually, if I remember correctly, Darth Vader... you, wanted to track them to their base, since ... you ... didn't know where it was yet. So you basically did a 200IQ convoluted plan to let them escape. It could also be plot armour, yes. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 12, 2020 15:07:26 GMT
Does anyone remember the stormtrooper from the new hope. At the beginning they crushed the rebals. The only reason they didn't kill Luke and the others because it would not look pleasing to the Audience. Actually, if I remember correctly, Darth Vader... you, wanted to track them to their base, since ... you ... didn't know where it was yet. So you basically did a 200IQ convoluted plan to let them escape. It could also be plot armour, yes. It was plot armor. The Jedi Yoda should have countinued fighting Sidious but instead he ran away to swamp plant. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Nihilus on Jun 12, 2020 15:13:53 GMT
Actually, if I remember correctly, Darth Vader... you, wanted to track them to their base, since ... you ... didn't know where it was yet. So you basically did a 200IQ convoluted plan to let them escape. It could also be plot armour, yes. It was plot armor. The Jedi Yoda should have countinued fighting Sidious but instead he ran away to swamp plant. I mean, he was like 900 years old, plus he fell 100 feet, so I wouldn't fight someone if I just fell 100 feet. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 12, 2020 16:00:46 GMT
I mean, he was like 900 years old, plus he fell 100 feet, so I wouldn't fight someone if I just fell 100 feet. Good point. That's like swoard fighting a Opponent on a airplane and then getting kicked off. But Yoda is a Jedi master so he could have killed him in his sleep. |
|
|
|
Post by steelixir on Jun 17, 2020 19:16:08 GMT
Does anyone remember the stormtrooper from the new hope. At the beginning they crushed the rebals. The only reason they didn't kill Luke and the others because it would not look pleasing to the Audience. I’ve noticed that at the beginning of both TFA and ANH, the bad guys absolutely decimated the rebels or the like, as a show of force, but as the movie goes on, they get progressively worse. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 17, 2020 19:23:59 GMT
Does anyone remember the stormtrooper from the new hope. At the beginning they crushed the rebals. The only reason they didn't kill Luke and the others because it would not look pleasing to the Audience. I’ve noticed that at the beginning of both TFA and ANH, the bad guys absolutely decimated the rebels or the like, as a show of force, but as the movie goes on, they get progressively worse. Yes, who knew a whole legion of stormtroopers got decimated by a bunch of teddy bears in the Return of the Jedi. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Nihilus on Jun 17, 2020 23:23:17 GMT
I’ve noticed that at the beginning of both TFA and ANH, the bad guys absolutely decimated the rebels or the like, as a show of force, but as the movie goes on, they get progressively worse. Yes, who knew a whole legion of stormtroopers got decimated by a bunch of teddy bears in the Return of the Jedi. Well... considering how the US did in the Vietnam War and how the USSR did in the Winter War, I'd say the demise of the stormtroopers in RoTJ is... mildly understandable. I'd give it a one out of ten in terms of realism, since there's no way Ewoks should be able to penetrate hybrid metal armour with wooden spears, but Guerrilla warfare works a lot better in practice than on paper. In TFA, I literally don't get what the First Order's trying to do. They destroyed the senate, but it's not like they wanted to replace it with their own government or anything. They're literally just terrorists. Even in the first scene the stormtroopers actually get held back pretty well by a bunch of villagers. Rey, the untrained scavenger, beats a Sith Lord. The First Order literally leaves their Death Star XL unguarded, and lets it get destroyed by a squadron of 20 x-wings. The amount of egregious plot holes has led me to actually start rewriting The Last Jedi lol. I even made a google docs. Zero out of ten. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 17, 2020 23:53:38 GMT
Yes, who knew a whole legion of stormtroopers got decimated by a bunch of teddy bears in the Return of the Jedi. Well... considering how the US did in the Vietnam War and how the USSR did in the Winter War, I'd say the demise of the stormtroopers in RoTJ is... mildly understandable. I'd give it a one out of ten in terms of realism, since there's no way Ewoks should be able to penetrate hybrid metal armour with wooden spears, but Guerrilla warfare works a lot better in practice than on paper. In TFA, I literally don't get what the First Order's trying to do. They destroyed the senate, but it's not like they wanted to replace it with their own government or anything. They're literally just terrorists. Even in the first scene the stormtroopers actually get held back pretty well by a bunch of villagers. Rey, the untrained scavenger, beats a Sith Lord. The First Order literally leaves their Death Star XL unguarded, and lets it get destroyed by a squadron of 20 x-wings. The amount of egregious plot holes has led me to actually start rewriting The Last Jedi lol. I even made a google docs. Zero out of ten. Have you seen the rise of Skywalker? Because if you haven't I don't want to spoil it. It's level of a good movie is about a 6-7. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Nihilus on Jun 18, 2020 1:02:10 GMT
Well... considering how the US did in the Vietnam War and how the USSR did in the Winter War, I'd say the demise of the stormtroopers in RoTJ is... mildly understandable. I'd give it a one out of ten in terms of realism, since there's no way Ewoks should be able to penetrate hybrid metal armour with wooden spears, but Guerrilla warfare works a lot better in practice than on paper. In TFA, I literally don't get what the First Order's trying to do. They destroyed the senate, but it's not like they wanted to replace it with their own government or anything. They're literally just terrorists. Even in the first scene the stormtroopers actually get held back pretty well by a bunch of villagers. Rey, the untrained scavenger, beats a Sith Lord. The First Order literally leaves their Death Star XL unguarded, and lets it get destroyed by a squadron of 20 x-wings. The amount of egregious plot holes has led me to actually start rewriting The Last Jedi lol. I even made a google docs. Zero out of ten. Have you seen the rise of Skywalker? Because if you haven't I don't want to spoil it. It's level of a good movie is about a 6-7. I haven't seen it but the amount of spoilers I've gotten is equivalent to me seeing it lol. |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on Jun 18, 2020 1:06:54 GMT
Darth Nihilus , ever sense Lucas sold star wars to Disney has made star wars terrible.
|
|
