|
|
Post by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus on Mar 14, 2021 17:26:53 GMT
Hey guys, I will soon make a critique of all the generals gog3 has to offer in the style of the ew4 guide I made last year as nonstop purple, yellow, and green text is tiring on the eyes.
Right now, I don’t have the most experience in the game but I’ll probably make the list of general quality tiers then review a general per day.
Meanwhile, If you want to help this list come sooner,
Fill out this survey, don’t go too indepth just a few words will get the job done. Also leave the numbers behind the answer for each question.
1. Who is your favorite non iap general in the game per unit type?
2. Which generals are the most underrated in your opinion?
3. Which generals are the most overrated in your opinion?
4. Who is the worst general in the game?
5. Who is the best first purchase general in the game?
I will also make a few polls on each of these questions once I get a couple of popular answers
|
|
|
|
Post by eeeeef on Mar 14, 2021 17:31:22 GMT
1. Goderian, Govorov, Yamashita, Donitz, Kesselring
2. Chuikov
3. Macarthur
4. Darlan
5. Badoglio
|
|
|
|
Post by eeeeef on Mar 14, 2021 17:35:57 GMT
Also just a heads up:
All generals in the 1-2 star medal range unless free, isn't worth reviewing imo since there are just so many of them and since you can't refund gens and you get free generals are all equally worthless
|
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus on Mar 14, 2021 17:37:09 GMT
1. Goderian, Govorov, Yamashita, Donitz, Kesselring 2. Chuikov 3. Macarthur 4. Darlan 5. Badoglio Great list. For #2, I was thinking of Voronov myself. I haven’t unlocked him yet, but he seems really strong for really cheap. Darlan is terrible I agree. Macarthur is strong but definitely seems too expensive. I was thinking Slim would be a nice alternative And what makes Badoglio so good if he lacks artillery leader? |
|
|
|
Post by eeeeef on Mar 14, 2021 17:42:03 GMT
1. Goderian, Govorov, Yamashita, Donitz, Kesselring 2. Chuikov 3. Macarthur 4. Darlan 5. Badoglio Great list. For #2, I was thinking of Voronov myself. I haven’t unlocked him yet, but he seems really strong for really cheap. Darlan is terrible I agree. Macarthur is strong but definitely seems too expensive. I was thinking Slim would be a nice alternative And what makes Badoglio so good if he lacks artillery leader? 2. Chuikov is literally free and he's ridiculously strong eliminating the need to buy govorov early on or to buy a second allied artillery gen 5. He has economics making him an invaluable asset in army group, he's not much worse than his competitor leeb lacking only lvl1 artillery leader, 12% crit, and 5 damage in exchange for speed and utility, and he's relatively cheap and available very early on. |
|
|
|
Post by HangryBird on Mar 14, 2021 18:12:44 GMT
1. Rundstedt, Guderian, Leeb, Donitz, Kesselring (In terms of strength). Model, Messe, Bock, Riccardi, Ozawa (In terms of memorability) 2. Vatutin, Slim 3. Hoth, Tassigny 4. Horthy 5. Guderian EDIT: Added Tassigny to overrated |
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus on Mar 14, 2021 18:22:18 GMT
Great list. For #2, I was thinking of Voronov myself. I haven’t unlocked him yet, but he seems really strong for really cheap. Darlan is terrible I agree. Macarthur is strong but definitely seems too expensive. I was thinking Slim would be a nice alternative And what makes Badoglio so good if he lacks artillery leader? 2. Chuikov is literally free and he's ridiculously strong eliminating the need to buy govorov early on or to buy a second allied artillery gen 5. He has economics making him an invaluable asset in army group, he's not much worse than his competitor leeb lacking only lvl1 artillery leader, 12% crit, and 5 damage in exchange for speed and utility, and he's relatively cheap and available very early on. Great points. I haven’t gotten around to eastern front so I didn’t know chuikov would be free. Then he really is a monster. Also agree about Badoglio. 6 gold is a lot of cash that can build up extremely quickly. I’ll definitely buy him and use him in conquest more often |
|
|
|
Post by eeeeef on Mar 14, 2021 18:24:34 GMT
2. Chuikov is literally free and he's ridiculously strong eliminating the need to buy govorov early on or to buy a second allied artillery gen 5. He has economics making him an invaluable asset in army group, he's not much worse than his competitor leeb lacking only lvl1 artillery leader, 12% crit, and 5 damage in exchange for speed and utility, and he's relatively cheap and available very early on. Great points. I haven’t gotten around to eastern front so I didn’t know chuikov would be free. Then he really is a monster. Also agree about Badoglio. 6 gold is a lot of cash that can build up extremely quickly. I’ll definitely buy him and use him in conquest more often You should look up the free generals in the game! There are 11 total 5 axis 6 allies and many of them are pretty strong generals. |
|
|
|
Post by Port on Mar 14, 2021 23:50:39 GMT
Hey guys, I will soon make a critique of all the generals gog3 has to offer in the style of the ew4 guide I made last year as nonstop purple, yellow, and green text is tiring on the eyes. Right now, I don’t have the most experience in the game but I’ll probably make the list of general quality tiers then review a general per day. Meanwhile, If you want to help this list come sooner, Fill out this survey, don’t go too indepth just a few words will get the job done. Also leave the numbers behind the answer for each question. 1. Who is your favorite non iap general in the game per unit type? 2. Which generals are the most underrated in your opinion? 3. Which generals are the most overrated in your opinion? 4. Who is the worst general in the game? 5. Who is the best first purchase general in the game? I will also make a few polls on each of these questions once I get a couple of popular answers Best first purchase general is (In My opinion) Guderian or the key to my Allies 1941 Eastern Front Success, Vatutin. After Guderian and Vatutin you should buy Govorov and Leeb by the Guadalcanal Campaign and Battle of Malaya Respectively. Again this is My opinion and is based off of my experiences. |
|
|
|
Post by Port on Mar 14, 2021 23:53:46 GMT
1. Rundstedt, Guderian, Leeb, Donitz, Kesselring (In terms of strength). Model, Messe, Bock, Riccardi, Ozawa (In terms of memorability) 2. Vatutin, Slim 3. Hoth 4. Horthy 5. Guderian Horthy? Hoth? ?? Could you please explain why these are up here. Horthy probably has less power than Darlan, and with Hoth you should save yourself some medals and get Graziani. |
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus on Mar 14, 2021 23:58:55 GMT
1. Rundstedt, Guderian, Leeb, Donitz, Kesselring (In terms of strength). Model, Messe, Bock, Riccardi, Ozawa (In terms of memorability) 2. Vatutin, Slim 3. Hoth 4. Horthy 5. Guderian Horthy? Hoth? ?? Could you please explain why these are up here. Horthy probably has less power than Darlan, and with Hoth you should save yourself some medals and get Graziani. He’s answering who the most overrated and worst general is. Hoth is overrated whereas Horthy is the worst. I don’t really think Hoth is overrated personally, everyone knows he is bad. For overrated, nagumo, monty, and tassigny is more of what I am looking for. Popular picks that you hate personally. |
|
|
|
Post by Port on Mar 15, 2021 0:19:47 GMT
Horthy? Hoth? ?? Could you please explain why these are up here. Horthy probably has less power than Darlan, and with Hoth you should save yourself some medals and get Graziani. He’s answering who the most overrated and worst general is. Hoth is overrated whereas Horthy is the worst. I don’t really think Hoth is overrated personally, everyone knows he is bad. For overrated, nagumo, monty, and tassigny is more of what I am looking for. Popular picks that you hate personally. Overacted Rokossovsky, bad Ushijima, overated Konev, bad Kuchler, bad Blamley. Underrrated Clark, Underrated Nenonen!, Underrated Voronov. |
|
|
|
Post by HangryBird on Mar 15, 2021 0:49:22 GMT
1. Rundstedt, Guderian, Leeb, Donitz, Kesselring (In terms of strength). Model, Messe, Bock, Riccardi, Ozawa (In terms of memorability) 2. Vatutin, Slim 3. Hoth 4. Horthy 5. Guderian Horthy? Hoth? ?? Could you please explain why these are up here. Horthy probably has less power than Darlan, and with Hoth you should save yourself some medals and get Graziani. I was following the format that was established by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus , as they pointed out earlier. |
|
|
|
Post by HangryBird on Mar 15, 2021 0:52:09 GMT
Horthy? Hoth? ?? Could you please explain why these are up here. Horthy probably has less power than Darlan, and with Hoth you should save yourself some medals and get Graziani. He’s answering who the most overrated and worst general is. Hoth is overrated whereas Horthy is the worst. I don’t really think Hoth is overrated personally, everyone knows he is bad. For overrated, nagumo, monty, and tassigny is more of what I am looking for. Popular picks that you hate personally. I've actually found that Hoth has some advocates in this board. Also, I forgot about Tassigny, he is way more overrated than Hoth. |
|
|
|
Post by Port on Mar 15, 2021 0:54:58 GMT
He’s answering who the most overrated and worst general is. Hoth is overrated whereas Horthy is the worst. I don’t really think Hoth is overrated personally, everyone knows he is bad. For overrated, nagumo, monty, and tassigny is more of what I am looking for. Popular picks that you hate personally. I've actually found that Hoth has some advocates in this board. Also, I forgot about Tassigny, he is way more overrated than Hoth. Tassigny is by no means overrated, and what about Horthy then? |
|
