|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 12:39:48 GMT
1. the 3nd axis artillery is bock , he have same stat with ushijima but he is free 2. desperate is a not good defensive skills , enemy still can ambush u and kill u , he still take damage from enemy counterattack 2. crowd tactics is a decent defenseive skill but it required alot of force 3. scout is a attack skills u need to go out and detect enemy not sit there yes , his skills doesnt work with each other , they doesnt help trigger other , ushijima is overpriced , his stat is kinda decent so conclusion ; THIS GUY SUCK 1. Bock's Leadership sucks on Artillery, and he is the third Axis tanker, not Artilleryman. 2. Desperate is not for demoralizing ordinary units, it is primarily for generals. They will take multiple turns to kill, and it will help them to give you less damage. 3. Ah Crowd Tactics... One, although it can be a defensive skill, I do not think it should be used as such. All of the + damage skills (with the potential exception of Street Fighting, and even that can be used offensively), are for pushing back the enemy. You'll find that crowd tactics is remarkably easy to trigger. 4. Yes, Scout is for going out into the frontlines, but his other skills are too. I see no disparity. Yes, again, I agree that he is somewhat overpriced, but worth it IMO. |
|
|
|
Post by STILETT0 on Jun 9, 2021 13:01:23 GMT
Cause Yama was too weak, and Leeb and Guderian were too cost-inefficient. Badoglio for life, suckas! also, it is pretty disappointing how nerfed Yama became in this game. He is only a small amount better than Tito who has one less skill and two less stars. I want the WC3 absolute murderer Yama to come back. This one became too nerfed. I thought that Yama vs Ruddy would be a no-brainer: Rud is slower, and Yama is cheaper, except that now I wonder if Gerd was a better buy, if I would have passed Pearl Harbor with him... |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 13:04:25 GMT
Badoglio for life, suckas! also, it is pretty disappointing how nerfed Yama became in this game. He is only a small amount better than Tito who has one less skill and two less stars. I want the WC3 absolute murderer Yama to come back. This one became too nerfed. I thought that Yama vs Ruddy would be a no-brainer: Rud is slower, and Yama is cheaper, except that now I wonder if Gerd was a better buy, if I would have passed Pearl Harbor with him... Gerd is better. By a lot. Infantry gens in general were buffed a lot, though. |
|
|
|
Post by imkhoa3 on Jun 9, 2021 17:30:33 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by imkhoa3 on Jun 9, 2021 17:33:02 GMT
u can still use bock as artillery
2. desperate is not agood , u still can get damage from counter,attack also enemy regain morales fast
|
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 17:47:54 GMT
Yes, as an infantry. Ushijima is a Hybrid. He is good enough at his job to warrant a purchase whereas Yamashita is not. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2021 17:50:29 GMT
Yes, as an infantry. Ushijima is a Hybrid. He is good enough at his job to warrant a purchase whereas Yamashita is not. Why get a hybrid though? the way i see it a one slot specialist is always better than a jack of all trades. If you are making the case for an inf-art hybrid being good than why do you dislike Alexander, who is free and has an actually useful skill/ |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2021 17:56:08 GMT
Yes, as an infantry. Ushijima is a Hybrid. He is good enough at his job to warrant a purchase whereas Yamashita is not. Also how is Yamashita not good at his Job? Let's just overview him real quick- - Four inf stars -Guerilla for survivability -Bayonet for raw power - Samurai means he can be flanked and not lose morale - Damage is consistent - Fast enough to keep up with blitzkrieg tactics and speedy tank generals. Compare that to Ushijima- - Three inf stars and art stars - Lacks any specialized skills for either - Scout is utterly garbage, is only useful if you use him as a suicide scout, which is what armoured cars and radars are for. - Desperate's not terrible but is better on tanks(ie Vatutin) -Crowd Tactics is OK but it means he needs to be near a city at all times to be able to heal enough to keep it consistent. - No damage skills -Slow This isnt even a debate. |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 18:09:51 GMT
u can still use bock as artillery 2. desperate is not agood , u still can get damage from counter,attack also enemy regain morales fast 1. Yes, but he is trash as one. All he has is two stars and PF lv. 1. Second, Desperate isn't meant to block enemy counterattack. It is meant to assist in demoralizing the enemy. |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 18:17:45 GMT
Yes, as an infantry. Ushijima is a Hybrid. He is good enough at his job to warrant a purchase whereas Yamashita is not. Why get a hybrid though? the way i see it a one slot specialist is always better than a jack of all trades. If you are making the case for an inf-art hybrid being good than why do you dislike Alexander, who is free and has an actually useful skill? I dislike Alexander because he sucks. He doesn't have any skills, even if his stars are amazing. Machinist level one is practically nothing, and Desert Fighting is useless at all times. If he had even Camouflage, I would use him a lot. He just has no skills. Manstein, that may have been true in previous games, but in this game, there are two factors. One, there are limited slots, which makes a hybrid general better because they can be in the lineup and be more than one thing. In addition, with it being divided into Axis and Allies, there are much less options for a good artillery for the Axis, and Ushi fits that role. |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 18:19:44 GMT
Yes, as an infantry. Ushijima is a Hybrid. He is good enough at his job to warrant a purchase whereas Yamashita is not. Also how is Yamashita not good at his Job? Let's just overview him real quick- - Four inf stars -Guerilla for survivability -Bayonet for raw power - Samurai means he can be flanked and not lose morale - Damage is consistent - Fast enough to keep up with blitzkrieg tactics and speedy tank generals. Compare that to Ushijima- - Three inf stars and art stars - Lacks any specialized skills for either - Scout is utterly garbage, is only useful if you use him as a suicide scout, which is what armoured cars and radars are for. - Desperate's not terrible but is better on tanks(ie Vatutin) -Crowd Tactics is OK but it means he needs to be near a city at all times to be able to heal enough to keep it consistent. - No damage skills -Slow This isnt even a debate. Yamashita is good at a job, but it is not a good one in my opinion. He is meant to be a spearhead in an attack, which infantry are not meant to do. His Guerilla is too inconsistent to be of use. His Bayonet and Samurai, again, is for a spearhead, but he will die far to easy from overextension. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2021 18:31:36 GMT
Also how is Yamashita not good at his Job? Let's just overview him real quick- - Four inf stars -Guerilla for survivability -Bayonet for raw power - Samurai means he can be flanked and not lose morale - Damage is consistent - Fast enough to keep up with blitzkrieg tactics and speedy tank generals. Compare that to Ushijima- - Three inf stars and art stars - Lacks any specialized skills for either - Scout is utterly garbage, is only useful if you use him as a suicide scout, which is what armoured cars and radars are for. - Desperate's not terrible but is better on tanks(ie Vatutin) -Crowd Tactics is OK but it means he needs to be near a city at all times to be able to heal enough to keep it consistent. - No damage skills -Slow This isn't even a debate. Yamashita is good at a job, but it is not a good one in my opinion. He is meant to be a spearhead in an attack, which infantry are not meant to do. His Guerilla is too inconsistent to be of use. His Bayonet and Samurai, again, is for a spearhead, but he will die far to easy from overextension. Yamashita doesn't necessarily have to be a spear head. He can be used as a distraction if you are willing to let him soak up a few hits. I've used him to distract generals while Guderian sneaks around the flank and wipes them out from behind. Not to mention, overextension isn't usually a problem as long as you are within decent range of a city. This is good because Yama has the speed to run to a city, heal up, and then get right back to the front line. He is also great for slipping around meat shields to wipe out soft targets like arty gens. |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Jun 9, 2021 18:53:52 GMT
Yamashita is good at a job, but it is not a good one in my opinion. He is meant to be a spearhead in an attack, which infantry are not meant to do. His Guerilla is too inconsistent to be of use. His Bayonet and Samurai, again, is for a spearhead, but he will die far to easy from overextension. Yamashita doesn't necessarily have to be a spear head. He can be used as a distraction if you are willing to let him soak up a few hits. I've used him to distract generals while Guderian sneaks around the flank and wipes them out from behind. Not to mention, overextension isn't usually a problem as long as you are within decent range of a city. This is good because Yama has the speed to run to a city, heal up, and then get right back to the front line. He is also great for slipping around meat shields to wipe out soft targets like arty gens. Any Infantry gen can do that. Speed can be given by SF if you really need it. And the idea, and the idea that Yama needs to be near a city is one thing you condemned Ushijima for. In addition, even if the AI accepts a distraction, then is it worth putting your best infantry on the line for it? |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 9, 2021 19:22:51 GMT
Yamashita doesn't necessarily have to be a spear head. He can be used as a distraction if you are willing to let him soak up a few hits. I've used him to distract generals while Guderian sneaks around the flank and wipes them out from behind. Not to mention, overextension isn't usually a problem as long as you are within decent range of a city. This is good because Yama has the speed to run to a city, heal up, and then get right back to the front line. He is also great for slipping around meat shields to wipe out soft targets like arty gens. Any Infantry gen can do that. Speed can be given by SF if you really need it. And the idea, and the idea that Yama needs to be near a city is one thing you condemned Ushijima for. In addition, even if the AI accepts a distraction, then is it worth putting your best infantry on the line for it? Allow me to clarify. He doesn't NEED to be near a city. It's just helpful because in case he gets swarmed you can sprint him back and heal him up real quick. Ushijima, on the other hand, needs to be if you want consistent output from his crowd tactics. And yes, putting your best infantry on the line can be worth it, because when it all comes down to it it's your tank generals who will do the heavy lifting. Infantry is support and is meant to break a path for the tankers to charge through. |
|
|
|
Post by imkhoa3 on Jun 10, 2021 4:27:26 GMT
ushijima is not an arty gen , even he have 2 stars arty , his skills is not arty
scout only work if u have karl
and other is not arty skills
xd
|
|
