|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 5:20:16 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by 𝘛𝘳𝘰𝘵𝘴𝘬𝘺 on Jun 19, 2021 6:03:35 GMT
 LassaleType of General : Cavalry
Price : 6 Emblems
I mean why him? Sure he has 5 movement stars and 5 cavalry stars, has strike and surprise. But he has very less survivability. Moreover, he has a completely useless skill - Mobility and an unnecessary skill in the form form of Sailor. Dombrowski or Radetzky, even Murat is a much better buy.What? He has all cavalary skills ! That min-dmg is not working in the android version, is unlucky I don't know if this is the same on ios - has anyone tested the output formula on ios ?)Sailor is quite a good additional skill for a cavalary general. Much better than, geography, fireproove etc. If I take AA as fun skill. Training stars are useless for a cavalary general - ranking up too fast, is the surviability problem - I made a thread with explanations. One hand for the snair In R7/8 he will be on 5 cheveron - He is not a defending meatshield. He has 5 movement, 5⭐. What you want more? And what can you find ? This guy costs $ but saves 🎖! Top out of the box. One of the best generals. A really sencefull investion. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 6:17:26 GMT
LassaleType of General : Cavalry
Price : 6 Emblems
I mean why him? Sure he has 5 movement stars and 5 cavalry stars, has strike and surprise. But he has very less survivability. Moreover, he has a completely useless skill - Mobility and an unnecessary skill in the form form of Sailor. Dombrowski or Radetzky, even Murat is a much better buy. What? He has all cavalary skills ! That min-dmg is not working in the android version, is unlucky I don't know if this is the same on ios - has anyone tested the output formula on ios ?)Sailor is quite a good additional skill for a cavalary general. Much better than, geography, fireproove etc. If I take AA as fun skill. Training stars are useless for a cavalary general - ranking up too fast, is the surviability problem - I made a thread with explanations. One hand for the snair In R7/8 he will be on 5 cheveron - He is not a defending meatschield. He has 5 movement, 5⭐. What you want more? And what can you find ? This guy costs $ but saves 🎖! Top out of the box. One of the best generals. A really sencefull investion. His 2 skills and his replacability made me rank him avg. Sailor is not really needed because land units rarely fight on seas. Even if he can fight on seas, he can fight only on cavalry. And useless Mobility. I feel that Dombrowski/Radetzky are a better deal. Giving them a saddle and pistol will make him much better than Lassale. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 8:33:54 GMT
 BarclayPrice: 6 Emblems Type of General: Land Hybrid Barclay is a terrible general. He has 3 stars in infantry which means he need some regrouping. Bugle is a great infantry skill. But War Master is not desirable. Are you considering him as a cavalry general? If yes, then your hopes are dashed as you know...Mobility is useless. I don't see one reason to buy him. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 8:48:46 GMT
BagrationType of General : Infantry/Fort
Price : 6 Emblems
Absolutely Terrible general in terms of an IAP. His fort skills would probably never be used. His 4 star infantry is supplemented only by Mass Fire and an unreliable Defense Art and unnecessary War Master. Looking at his fort trainer, he probably is the costliest Fort trainer (Another bad skill as he is expensive). The only thing he has is a good survivability and average output (See Russian conquests). |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 10:37:15 GMT
PagetType of General : Cavalry
Price : 6 Emblems
Paget...firstly, this guy has some cool 4 stars in cavalry. Strike? Great, but what else? Sure Assault Art is good but unreliable. Mobility is useless. Do you consider him as an economic general? We have Arnold for medals and FROM THE START and much cheaper. If you consider him as a general who will fight, then Economic Expert is useless. Assault Art is based on Chance, which I hate. Of course he has strike, but so does Dombrowski and Radetzky. On top of that, he lacks survivability. Not good in my opinion. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 10:42:19 GMT
 TrevilleType of General: Navy Price: 6 Emblems Another bad general. Why would you buy him, when you already have Nelson? The reasons not to buy him? 1. War Expert is not desirablr. 2. Navy trainer for an IAP? Absolutely Awful. 3. Unlike Nelson, this guy has no land ability whatsoever. 4. There isn't place for a pure (and horrible) navy general for 4 slots. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 10:56:26 GMT
SuchetType of General : Infantry/Cavalry
Price : 8 Emblems
Suchet has 4 stars in infantry and 4 stars in cavalry. 4 movement stars are great and helps him to move fast. However, the main problem lies with his skills again; which are useless. Infantry Tactics? Useless. Mobility? Useless. Fireproof? Useless on land, useful on ships, but he has no naval stars. Spy is...practically the only skill he has. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 11:08:27 GMT
 Alexander IType of General : Fort/Business
Price : 6 Emblems
AH!! MY EYES BURN BY LOOKING AT HIS STATS!! Why would anyone even buy him? I mean, generals on forts are rarely used. 2 star infantry and cavalry? Absolutely awful! Let me guess; after saving up your hard earned 6$, resisting every temptation (Even that of buying new pair of shoes [Not from US perspective]), purchasing emblems, refreshing Tier 1 section 293 times, you finally buy him only to realize that he is absolutely horrible and he is replaced by Arnold, from the start and he costs medals! I am sorry for your pain  |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 11:19:48 GMT
CottonType of General: Cavalry Price: 6 Emblems In my rating, he was destinied to be going into Red, but he still has Spy and Strike and 4 cavalry stars so he isn't probably that bad. However, he has bad survivability. Sailor is not necessary and Cavalry Trainer is not desirable in such an expensive general. So he manages to stay afloat, albeit barely. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 11:22:17 GMT
Oh no! College is going to open from July and I don't know if I can complete it and other works in time. I might get very little time or probably have to go inactive for at least 2 years.
|
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Jun 19, 2021 11:33:40 GMT
 DesaixType of General : Hybrid
Price : 6 Emblems
STILETT0 isn't bad as I initially thought. War Master, for sure isn't reliable. But he still is so near replacement for Sakurako. Strike Bugle Accurate for all 3 tyoes and he has 2 star on navy too. Though he has less survivability, he still is very good. Probably the third best hybrid after Davout, Sakurako. |
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus on Jun 19, 2021 14:26:37 GMT
 DearbornPrice: 8 Emblems Type of General: Infantry (Land Hybrid, but no skills)/Economic general Scenario one 1 : You have just purchased some emblems and you come across this man. "Wow! Shiny stars! And since John Marston refused me to buy himself Napoleon...so, I will buy him! *5 minutes later* What! such a crap general! I regret my buy! Scenario 2 : You waited me to complete my analysis of Dearborn (Thank You for that  ) and you learn that Dearborn is actually not a good general! His mainstay is infantry, but he has only formation and bugle for that. Architecture is a good skill, but it's not enough as an economic general. War Expert is not desirable. Sure, he has 5 star movement, which is great, but he cannot take may hits. Also, he has 5 stars in trading, which means he is inferior to Arnold, who is available from the start! and costs medals only. He is a Must "NOT" - Buy. My point exactly. As an economic general, he is Kosciusko with tall boots. As a city defense general, he is absolute garbage as he’ll be demoralised very easily and lacks mass fire. As an Infantry general, he is a fast Oudinot. Ultimately buying Dearborn is like buying a slightly better Fatimah. But the original is easy to unlock so why do we need a second? |
|
|
|
Post by 𝘛𝘳𝘰𝘵𝘴𝘬𝘺 on Jun 19, 2021 16:01:53 GMT
What? He has all cavalary skills ! That min-dmg is not working in the android version, is unlucky I don't know if this is the same on ios - has anyone tested the output formula on ios ?)Sailor is quite a good additional skill for a cavalary general. Much better than, geography, fireproove etc. If I take AA as fun skill. Training stars are useless for a cavalary general - ranking up too fast, is the surviability problem - I made a thread with explanations. One hand for the snair In R7/8 he will be on 5 cheveron - He is not a defending meatshield. He has 5 movement, 5⭐. What you want more? And what can you find ? This guy costs $ but saves 🎖! Top out of the box. One of the best generals. A really sencefull investion. His 2 skills and his replacability made me rank him avg. Sailor is not really needed because land units rarely fight on seas. Even if he can fight on seas, he can fight only on cavalry. And useless Mobility. I feel that Dombrowski/Radetzky are a better deal. Giving them a saddle and pistol will make him much better than Lassale. How can be Radetzky a better deal  Radetzky costs +33% and offers less output (- 1⭐ cavalary, -mobility) He has less movement -2 movement ! Even if you throw +1500🎖 on top to the 33% higer basic price for Radetzky to compare them, he will be never better in attack than Lassalle. But he has a 10% change to reduce recieved dammage to a minimum, and nobleman - quite expensive. Before you also raked down Moreau because he has on top 4⭐ infantry that are not used. This is a logical error: - A general can't get downraked, because he offers unused stars on top. For a mission in the campaign - like always |
|
|
|
Post by 𝘛𝘳𝘰𝘵𝘴𝘬𝘺 on Jun 19, 2021 16:47:18 GMT
His 2 skills and his replacability made me rank him avg. Sailor is not really needed because land units rarely fight on seas. Even if he can fight on seas, he can fight only on cavalry. And useless Mobility. I feel that Dombrowski/Radetzky are a better deal. Giving them a saddle and pistol will make him much better than Lassale. How can be Radetzky a better deal Radetzky costs +33% and offers less output (- 1⭐ cavalary, -mobility) He has less movement -2 movement ! Even if you throw +1500🎖 on top to the 33% higer basic price for Radetzky to compare them, he will be never better in attack than Lassalle. But he has a 10% change to reduce recieved dammage to a minimum, and nobleman - quite expensive. [/quote]We play EW4. Navy generals have a reduced usability. For sure I use cavalary for sea battles - what else (+50%)? And it is far the best to get quickly rid of all costall forts on top. MassFire works only for infantry, so a cavalary general needs practical always a snair. It is extrem usefull to have one slot for attack or defense items disponibile. Sailor is (only) for cavalary a really usefull skill - not maybe not good as leadership, but used more often. |
|
) and you learn that Dearborn is actually not a good general!
