|
|
Post by imkhoa3 on Sept 18, 2021 15:03:43 GMT
first , stats ( montgomery win )
uhm... i need to explain ? same speed but montgomery have better stats and 3 stars airs
skills
machinist lv2 vs machinist lv1 ( monty win ) : no need to explain.... too easy to understand
panzer leader lv2 : same
ace commander vs anti armor ( roko win ): ace comamnder suck when you have max tech , anti armor is good because it can help you shred tank and armor which is a common spam
price , roko cheaper ( abit )
so this is a question : what to choose ? anti armor lv2 , 105 medals or 1 star armor , 3 stars air , lv2 machinist
i will let you guys decide it
|
|
|
|
Post by 6Johnny23 on Sept 18, 2021 16:09:59 GMT
first , stats ( montgomery win ) uhm... i need to explain ? same speed but montgomery have better stats and 3 stars airs skills machinist lv2 vs machinist lv1 ( monty win ) : no need to explain.... too easy to understand panzer leader lv2 : same ace commander vs anti armor ( roko win ): ace comamnder suck when you have max tech , anti armor is good because it can help you shred tank and armor which is a common spam price , roko cheaper ( abit ) so this is a question : what to choose ? anti armor lv2 , 105 medals or 1 star armor , 3 stars air , lv2 machinist i will let you guys decide it 1. Monty's air you will rarely use, as tanks are supposed to be in the front, not commanding planes in the back. Still a win for Monty as 1* more in tanks. 2. Machinist is trash, and you will recruit instead of replenish unless you are short of cash. Still, I find that it barely makes a difference. Roko wins, if you hit every single army unit once without the PL chance, Roko will out-damage Monty. Still, this difference is miniscule. |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Sept 18, 2021 17:40:46 GMT
first , stats ( montgomery win ) uhm... i need to explain ? same speed but montgomery have better stats and 3 stars airs skills machinist lv2 vs machinist lv1 ( monty win ) : no need to explain.... too easy to understand panzer leader lv2 : same ace commander vs anti armor ( roko win ): ace comamnder suck when you have max tech , anti armor is good because it can help you shred tank and armor which is a common spam price , roko cheaper ( abit ) so this is a question : what to choose ? anti armor lv2 , 105 medals or 1 star armor , 3 stars air , lv2 machinist i will let you guys decide it 1. Monty's air you will rarely use, as tanks are supposed to be in the front, not commanding planes in the back. Still a win for Monty as 1* more in tanks. 2. Machinist is trash, and you will recruit instead of replenish unless you are short of cash. Still, I find that it barely makes a difference. Roko wins, if you hit every single army unit once without the PL chance, Roko will out-damage Monty. Still, this difference is miniscule. Air can still be useful if Monty takes an airport at the front. Machinist gold isn't bad, it is about equal (with 0 stars) to a rull recruit, with 2 stars as I had Monty it is about 2/3 |
|
|
|
Post by 6Johnny23 on Sept 18, 2021 17:44:23 GMT
1. Monty's air you will rarely use, as tanks are supposed to be in the front, not commanding planes in the back. Still a win for Monty as 1* more in tanks. 2. Machinist is trash, and you will recruit instead of replenish unless you are short of cash. Still, I find that it barely makes a difference. Roko wins, if you hit every single army unit once without the PL chance, Roko will out-damage Monty. Still, this difference is miniscule. Air can still be useful if Monty takes an airport at the front. Machinist gold isn't bad, it is about equal (with 0 stars) to a rull recruit, with 2 stars as I had Monty it is about 2/3 What are the chances of that? Monty waltzes into an airport. You will probably use that money for your main army and if not, you will probably have Dowding/Halsey with the planes. Recruiting is better and you will want to max out Monty's stars. Machinist is only good if you are desperate. |
|
|
|
Post by Lucklife on Sept 18, 2021 17:48:32 GMT
Air can still be useful if Monty takes an airport at the front. Machinist gold isn't bad, it is about equal (with 0 stars) to a rull recruit, with 2 stars as I had Monty it is about 2/3 What are the chances of that? Monty waltzes into an airport. You will probably use that money for your main army and if not, you will probably have Dowding/Halsey with the planes. Recruiting is better and you will want to max out Monty's stars. Machinist is only good if you are desperate. It's all about playstyle... There are quite a few missions across 1944, 1945, where you rack up extra money, which can be used for air force. When I see that I need an objective or tactical location and the airport is nearby, just roll monty in and use air force to clear some key troops... |
|
|
|
Post by truhses on Sept 19, 2021 0:31:41 GMT
And again, inquiring minds are tormented by the eternal question: useless Ace forces or stars in aviation? Stylish beret or luxurious marshal's cap? English snob or Soviet Pole? West or East? To be or not to be....
|
|
|
|
Post by Boss Tweed on Sept 19, 2021 1:48:50 GMT
And again, inquiring minds are tormented by the eternal question: useless Ace forces or stars in aviation? Stylish beret or luxurious marshal's cap? English snob or Soviet Pole? West or East? To be or not to be.... Would rather take the English Snob over Soviet Pole due to more consistent damage output. |
|
|
|
Post by 曹操 on Sept 19, 2021 6:30:14 GMT
Just buy both for Achievement although just like i always say Vatutin is the best for damage, Roko has Best skill, uhmm not so great damage, good mobility. While Monty is combination of Both Vatutin and Roko Fast and Great damage but not really good skill
|
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Sept 19, 2021 6:34:28 GMT
Ask yourself these 3 questions.
1. When my KV6 encounters a mob, what does it mostly consist of?
Armored: 1 point to Rokossovsky. Infantry and/or artillery: 1 point to Montgomery.
2. Do I want to deploy 6 generals in Africa 1941 and/or Western 1944?
Yes but I don't wanna get Patton and I don't have Eisenhower: 1 point to Montgomery. No/yes and I'm getting Patton/I have Eisenhower: 1 point to the winner of Q1.
3. Do you replenish often?
Yes: 1 point to Montgomery. No: 1 point to the winner of Q1.
Now you have your answer.
|
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Sept 19, 2021 14:04:43 GMT
1 extra star for 105 medals is not good. Rokossovsky all way.
|
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Sept 19, 2021 14:12:53 GMT
1 extra star for 105 medals is not good. Rokossovsky all way. One star, 3 air, an extra level of machinist, better lineups, and AF is better than Anti-Armor and 105 medals, though. |
|
|
|
Post by Gerd von Rundstedt on Sept 19, 2021 14:14:25 GMT
Ask yourself these 3 questions. 1. When my KV6 encounters a mob, what does it mostly consist of? Armored: 1 point to Rokossovsky. Infantry and/or artillery: 1 point to Montgomery. 2. Do I want to deploy 6 generals in Africa 1941 and/or Western 1944? Yes but I don't wanna get Patton and I don't have Eisenhower: 1 point to Montgomery. No/yes and I'm getting Patton/I have Eisenhower: 1 point to the winner of Q1. 3. Do you replenish often? Yes: 1 point to Montgomery. No: 1 point to the winner of Q1. Now you have your answer. Q1. Point to Monty. Q2. Point to Monty Q3. Point to Q1. 3 points to Monty wins. |
|
|
|
Post by John Marston on Sept 19, 2021 14:36:12 GMT
1 extra star for 105 medals is not good. Rokossovsky all way. One star, 3 air, an extra level of machinist, better lineups, and AF is better than Anti-Armor and 105 medals, though. 1. I don't replenish. 2. Lineups doesn't matter for me because my allied generals are limited. 3. One star is negligible and Roko does more damage to the most tanky units - Armored ones. Bonus - I don't have a medal income now except for daily rewards. 105 matter a lot for me. |
|
|
|
Post by 6Johnny23 on Sept 19, 2021 15:15:54 GMT
1 extra star for 105 medals is not good. Rokossovsky all way. One star, 3 air, an extra level of machinist, better lineups, and AF is better than Anti-Armor and 105 medals, though. 3* air is situational and you have Halsey/Dowding. Machinist is near useless, replenishing gets worse while your generals get better. Lineups don't really matter, there are barely any good generals for the Allies and you definitely want Roko anyways. They only notable lineups are Western Front 1944, something if you get Vatutin or Patton I believe it will be easier, like if you get Monty. AF is pretty much near useless. That said, if you can stick through that 1 week of grinding, he can be a big help. |
|
|
|
Post by Manfred von Richthofen on Sept 19, 2021 23:53:59 GMT
Eh. Hard one. Roko seems good, but Monty has more damage. hard choice but Rokossovsky.
*flashbacks of me as Rokossovsky*
|
|
