|
|
Post by NetherFreek on May 11, 2016 17:57:25 GMT
Hi, In this series im going to show you some stats according to a general that doesnt exist (also not in real). Afterwards im going to ask you whether you would buy him or not. (And i hope for argumentation  ) Everyday im going to add a new general and ill reset the poll  if you have suggestions for a general, pm me! Current Generals General #1 (Click)(1 pro, 1 against) General #2 (Click) (0 pro, 4 against) General #3 (Click) (4 pro, 4 against) General #4 (Click) (2 pro, 4 against) General #5 (Click) (3 pro, 3 against) General #6 (Click) (5 pro, 1 against) General #7 (Click) (1 pro, 6 against) General #8 (Click) (3 pro, 4 against) General #9 (Click) (4 yes, 3 no) General #10 (1 yes, 5 no) General #11 (0 yes, 5 no) |
|
|
|
Post by NetherFreek on May 11, 2016 18:09:34 GMT
general #1
Infantery -
Tank ***
Artillery *
Air ****
Navy -
Movement *****
Lvl 4 city fighting
Lvl 2 plain fighting
Lvl 2 shelter expert
Lvl 1 tide of iron
Major 100 lives
Price 1600 medals
Redenation to buy him:
He can move quickly from city to city. And after he moves to another city, he bombards the enemies. When an enemy unit dare to chalenge him he has plain and city fighting. Meaning +30 attack in cities, leaving alone his stars. Although hes not a starting general, he could eventually replace göring as a land air general.
Redenation not to buy him:
He is lacking the finail air star meaning 8 damage. And where do you need an air general for? Yes, bombing! And with that, he cant beat gens like göring who are almost half his price. And actually, his price isnt 1600, his live is lacking. So you need another 1000 to set this right. And who would buy a general with less output than göring who is 3 times more expensive than him?
Result
Yes: 1
No: 1
|
|
|
|
Post by wollesu on May 11, 2016 18:14:04 GMT
Hi, In this series im going to show you some stats according to a general that doesnt exist (also not in real). Afterwards im going to ask you whether you would buy him or not. (And i hope for argumentation ) Anyways, the first general Infantery - Tank *** Artillery * Air **** Navy - Movement ***** Lvl 4 city fighting Lvl 2 plain fighting Lvl 2 shelter expert Lvl 1 tide of iron Major 100 lives Price 1600 medals Redenation to buy him: He can move quickly from city to city. And after he moves to another city, he bombards the enemies. When an enemy unit dare to chalenge him he has plain and city fighting. Meaning +30 attack in cities, leaving alone his stars. Redenation not to buy him: He is lacking the finail air star meaning 8 damage. And where do you need an air general for? Yes, bombing! And with that, he cant beat gens like göring who are almost half his price. And actually, his price isnt 1600, his live is lacking. So you need another 1000 to set this right. And who would buy a general with less output than göring who is 3 times more expensive than him? That's Yamashita but on tank but worse and it is good for intermediary players imo |
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on May 11, 2016 18:52:55 GMT
Break through: no.
Enjoying: yes.
|
|
|
|
Post by NetherFreek on May 11, 2016 19:59:53 GMT
I wouldnt reccomend him,
Göring on a motorized inf is fast enough, his output isnt high enough. Yes, he deals a lot of damage back when someone tries to attack him, but only a few times since his lifes are lacking. Hes definitely an air general and usely air generals dont fight on the front so the plain and city skills dont trigger much. Furthermore the price is a bit dissapointment, you need to spend money on promotion so he has more life. So hell be around 2800 medals, and for that price there are a lot of better generals than him
|
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on May 11, 2016 20:05:27 GMT
I wouldnt reccomend him, Göring on a motorized inf is fast enough, his output isnt high enough. Yes, he deals a lot of damage back when someone tries to attack him, but only a few times since his lifes are lacking. Hes definitely an air general and usely air generals dont fight on the front so the plain and city skills dont trigger much. Furthermore the price is a bit dissapointment, you need to spend money on promotion so he has more life. So hell be around 2800 medals, and for that price there are a lot of better generals than him Patton is very enough as a tank-air general. |
|
|
|
Post by wollesu on May 12, 2016 6:32:12 GMT
If he has higher HP and 1 more Star I could consider buying him
|
|
|
|
Post by NetherFreek on May 12, 2016 13:51:30 GMT
General #2
Infantery -
Tank ****
artillery *
Air -
Navy -
Movement **
Skills
Tank leader lvl 2
Tide of iron lvl 3
Oil expert lvl 2
Captain 80
Price 750
Redenation to buy him:
He is very cheap but still 3 stars with a reasonable skill (tide of iron lvl3). Furthermore his rank is captain (+80 lives), so he has health enough to make it through axis and allies. The way to guderian can be devestating and the lack of having a tank general till you can buy him can break you. So he fits perfectly as a cheap but decent starting general like badoglio.
Redenation not to buy him:
This guy is indeed great for axis and allies, but beyond that he simply sucks. Why wasting so many medals on a general that you only have for a limited amount of time?
Result
Yes 0
No 4
|
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on May 12, 2016 13:54:21 GMT
Not considering him at all. I rather buy Devers.
|
|
|
|
Post by wollesu on May 12, 2016 14:59:54 GMT
Not considering him at all. I rather buy Devers. Agreed |
|
|
|
Post by NetherFreek on May 13, 2016 14:47:11 GMT
General #3
Infantery **
Tank **
Artillery **
Air ****
Navy ***
Movement *****
Plain fighting lvl 3
Street fighting lvl 3
Mountain fighting lvl 3
Desert fighting lvl 3
Jungle fighting lvl 3
Rank
General 230
Price 3000
Redenation to buy him:
His stats may not look impressive, but his 5 star movement could be handy. According to his skills you get +15 everywhere. +2 stars meand that he deals +29 damage on avarage and to compare, 4 stars deals +26 damage. So hes basiccaly 4 stars everywhere.
Furthermore There are little artillery generals that can move, 4 star arty and 5 stars movy are looking great! So he would rock on artillery
But if thats not enough for you to be convinced he also has another speciality, namely air. His street and plain makes him perfect for defending. He gets +30 in cities so other units will regret the decision to attack him. His 4 air stars makes him kill the enemies. His incredibly high health will make sure that 1 nuke cant stop him.
Redenation to not buy him:
The redenation of him having 4 arty stars is all wrong, does the plain fighting of guderian and govorov mean they have 7 or 8 stars? No. And even if so, guderian and govorov still have other skills which he dont have. So his output is still low in comparisinf to other gens.
Also he aint a great air general, the 5th star means 8 damage instead of 6, which is a lot if you miss that each strike on and on.
So he is basicelly equally strong on this area as ozawa (both 4 air and 3 navy), but ozawa is 550 medals and this guy 3000
If you need a movy art dude, bay would be better, he has higher stats and is cheaper.
To conclude i wouldnt spend 3000 medals in a general thats mediocre in everything while there are generals around 1000 medals who are better than him.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jean-Luc Picard on May 13, 2016 16:06:32 GMT
There are no fast artillery-air guys, but then again who wants artillery-air anyway?
|
|
|
|
Post by Singlemalt on May 13, 2016 16:45:07 GMT
There are no fast artillery-air guys, but then again who wants artillery-air anyway? I do against aliens.. I would defenitly get him |
|
|
|
Post by Jean-Luc Picard on May 13, 2016 16:55:34 GMT
There are no fast artillery-air guys, but then again who wants artillery-air anyway? I do against aliens.. I would defenitly get him I suppose, I just haven't reached Aliens yet |
|
|
|
Post by cardbattler on May 13, 2016 17:24:45 GMT
There are no fast artillery-air guys, but then again who wants artillery-air anyway? I do against aliens.. I would defenitly get him air is mostly for late games when you have tons of money and even so you'll mostly be investing in nukes anyway. |
|
)
