|
|
Post by hrabrimalitoster on Nov 2, 2021 11:38:31 GMT
After a serious discussion about what General Sertorius was like, I tested him and Vercingetorix on the battlefield as a punching bag. Because of the accuracy of the test, I gave them exactly the same items.   First go Sertorius  The general just sits in the city and does nothing but defend against the opponent, only attacks the archers. Here are the results.  Then go Vercingetorix  We do the same thing  The result is such that Vercingetorix has proven to be a better punching bag. |
|
|
|
Post by hrabrimalitoster on Nov 2, 2021 11:45:08 GMT
And these are the results when Vercingetorix gets the best items and realizes its full potential  It becomes one blow beast  Which allows it to save far more hp |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 2, 2021 11:59:22 GMT
After a serious discussion about what General Sertorius was like, I tested him and Vercingetorix on the battlefield as a punching bag. Because of the accuracy of the test, I gave them exactly the same items. First go Sertorius The general just sits in the city and does nothing but defend against the opponent, only attacks the archers. Here are the results. Then go Vercingetorix We do the same thing The result is such that Vercingetorix has proven to be a better punching bag. You should try it for atleast 10 times, or more to reduce the effect of rng. Also, the results would be more interesting if you give Sertorius the banner of Vulcan. Number wise, it simply comes down to how good shield wall is vs Sertorius' talent. |
|
|
|
Post by hrabrimalitoster on Nov 2, 2021 12:34:26 GMT
Deleted,I tried 5 times and these are average results, only once Sertorius was better by a modest 5 hp.
|
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Nov 2, 2021 21:57:46 GMT
Just do the math.
The formula of damage received after being reduced by unit defense (let's call it d) is (9d+1850)/(28d+1850), let's call this f(d).
For Sentry, the expected damage taken is 0.15f(2d)+0.85f(d).
For level 1 Shield Wall, it's 0.06[f(d)/2]+0.94f(d)=0.97f(d).
For them to have the same effect, 0.15f(2d)=0.12f(d), which means they are equal only when f(d)=1.25f(2d), which is impossible as long as d is positive.
Conclusion: Shield Wall > Sentry.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 2, 2021 22:28:06 GMT
Just do the math. The formula of damage received after being reduced by unit defense (let's call it d) is (9d+1850)/(28d+1850), let's call this f(d). For Sentry, the expected damage taken is 0.15f(2d)+0.85f(d). For level 1 Shield Wall, it's 0.06[f(d)/2]+0.94f(d)=0.97f(d). For them to have the same effect, 0.15f(2d)=0.12f(d), which means they are equal only when f(d)=1.25f(2d), which is impossible as long as d is positive. Conclusion: Shield Wall > Sentry. The numbers don't lie. |
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 2, 2021 22:29:24 GMT
Deleted ,I tried 5 times and these are average results, only once Sertorius was better by a modest 5 hp. Yeah, the result will be obvious because of the numbers, but it would look more convincing to others with more testing. |
|
