|
|
Post by Josip Broz Tito on Jul 17, 2022 2:55:23 GMT
Samurai aids damage, not survivability. Fine, but Samurai goes well with Mobility. Maybe Rundstedt has better survivability, but than the damage gap is smaller. |
|
|
|
Post by Boss Tweed on Jul 18, 2022 2:46:31 GMT
Samurai aids damage, not survivability. Fine, but Samurai goes well with Mobility. Maybe Rundstedt has better survivability, but than the damage gap is smaller. IMO samurai is both useless and redundant. Useless because most of the time infantry general on extremely low morale would also be on extremely low health: maintaining morale would barely help in that situation. Redundant because other special forces have anti-moral drop. |
|
|
|
Post by Josip Broz Tito on Jul 18, 2022 4:27:27 GMT
Fine, but Samurai goes well with Mobility. Maybe Rundstedt has better survivability, but than the damage gap is smaller. IMO samurai is both useless and redundant. Useless because most of the time infantry general on extremely low morale would also be on extremely low health: maintaining morale would barely help in that situation. Redundant because other special forces have anti-moral drop. But those are crappy. I’d rather Yama with Panzergrenadier than Rundstedt with Patriot. That being said Rundstedt with Wiking is better than Yama with Wiking. Plus, with Samurai you can get away with aggressive placements. |
|
|
|
Post by Kliment Jefremovitš Vorošilov on Jul 18, 2022 7:46:44 GMT
IMO samurai is both useless and redundant. Useless because most of the time infantry general on extremely low morale would also be on extremely low health: maintaining morale would barely help in that situation. Redundant because other special forces have anti-moral drop. But those are crappy. I’d rather Yama with Panzergrenadier than Rundstedt with Patriot. That being said Rundstedt with Wiking is better than Yama with Wiking. Plus, with Samurai you can get away with aggressive placements. Why? With the SF the only difference in damage is +6, IL and +36% against tanks vs +12, Bayonet and +42% against tanks. That is, I'd say pretty similar overall damage against tanks and against other units, a win for Rundstedt. But as for survivability, Rundstedt's Plunder Supply can essily make up for Grenadier's damage reduction. 12% HP is often much more than what you avoid with Grenadier. |
|
|
|
Post by Josip Broz Tito on Jul 18, 2022 15:26:54 GMT
But those are crappy. I’d rather Yama with Panzergrenadier than Rundstedt with Patriot. That being said Rundstedt with Wiking is better than Yama with Wiking. Plus, with Samurai you can get away with aggressive placements. Why? With the SF the only difference in damage is +6, IL and +36% against tanks vs +12, Bayonet and +42% against tanks. That is, I'd say pretty similar overall damage against tanks and against other units, a win for Rundstedt. But as for survivability, Rundstedt's Plunder Supply can essily make up for Grenadier's damage reduction. 12% HP is often much more than what you avoid with Grenadier. Fine, but Yama is faster, +6 extra + Bayonet is at least equal to IL, and Grenadier's damage reduction pays of when fighting powerful HT gens, which is when most people use Anti-Tank. |
|
|
|
Post by Josip Broz Tito on Aug 18, 2022 2:08:58 GMT
This post has been edited to represent my current opinions.
|
|
