|
|
Post by Just One Bite on Jan 29, 2024 8:00:52 GMT
ECs are much more expensive to build. Overall cost it is, but paying a huge sum in one go or spreading it out over a long period is not the same. Then why do you mention it? OP was asking for artillery generals that it could afford for around <2k medals. |
|
|
|
Post by resiphius on Jan 29, 2024 14:59:59 GMT
Overall cost it is, but paying a huge sum in one go or spreading it out over a long period is not the same. Then why do you mention it? OP was asking for artillery generals that it could afford for around <2k medals. It is you who brought it up and veered the topic first, I mentioned ECs because you said Govorov is needed in the end anyway and I disagreed, all counter I made afterward is the continue of this topic. As for OP’s question, Sikorski will be the good deal he can use all the way to endgame, while Govorov will be expensive to just catch up everybody’s marching pace (cost +300 ~ +900 medals), and I see even an infantry-artillery build or tank-artillery build EC will be no less capable than Govorov in terms of endgame, let alone a dedicated artillery EC. |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Jan 29, 2024 18:45:02 GMT
i asked in the discord and they also said govorov, maybe sikorski will be 2nd arty for me since ive spent practically all of my medals on gov edit: i felt too guilty and am resetting to go get sikorski What have you done… Please don't reset over such small decisions i have a save with the 1800ish medals needed to buy either, rn i have sikorski |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Jan 29, 2024 18:48:24 GMT
Then why do you mention it? OP was asking for artillery generals that it could afford for around <2k medals. It is you who brought it up and veered the topic first, I mentioned ECs because you said Govorov is needed in the end anyway and I disagreed, all counter I made afterward is the continue of this topic. As for OP’s question, Sikorski will be the good deal he can use all the way to endgame, while Govorov will be expensive to just catch up everybody’s marching pace (cost +300 ~ +900 medals), and I see even an infantry-artillery build or tank-artillery build EC will be no less capable than Govorov in terms of endgame, let alone a dedicated artillery EC. i was originally asking for <1k medal generals that are any good, it seems only crerar and ozawa (he is sorta redundant, replaced by sansonetti) are good in that price bracket also what is ec? |
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Jan 30, 2024 6:19:40 GMT
radomir000 EC is the xx commander you get for free. They are very expensive to upgrade, but also extremely powerful when well-developed. As an early game player, Govorov is a better fit for you but I would still recommend trying a bit harder for Guderian. Just One Bite resiphius Here's my thought on Sikorski vs Govorov: if you can freely pick the medals and the two NEVER move together, then Govorov's pros against artillery + assault Sikorski are only explosives and movement. However, we also need to take practicality into consideration. Sikorski, when equipped with 2 artillery medals, doesn't have a huge advantage against Govorov. Tank ECs have the top priority when it comes to assault medals and need them in large quantity, meaning it will take a very long time before Sikorski gets one, not to mention the air generals might want them as well. Artillery + combo Sikorski has no reason to split up with Govorov. As for artillery EC, I don't think it's as favorable as tank or infantry EC at endgame.
|
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Jan 30, 2024 8:22:41 GMT
radomir000 EC is the xx commander you get for free. They are very expensive to upgrade, but also extremely powerful when well-developed. As an early game player, Govorov is a better fit for you but I would still recommend trying a bit harder for Guderian. Just One Bite resiphius Here's my thought on Sikorski vs Govorov: if you can freely pick the medals and the two NEVER move together, then Govorov's pros against artillery + assault Sikorski are only explosives and movement. However, we also need to take practicality into consideration. Sikorski, when equipped with 2 artillery medals, doesn't have a huge advantage against Govorov. Tank ECs have the top priority when it comes to assault medals and need them in large quantity, meaning it will take a very long time before Sikorski gets one, not to mention the air generals might want them as well. Artillery + combo Sikorski has no reason to split up with Govorov. As for artillery EC, I don't think it's as favorable as tank or infantry EC at endgame. I'll go begin saving now for a decent tank commander - what are the best options even on a budget? I have Sikorski, crerar and three unupgraded EC |
|
|
|
Post by Just One Bite on Jan 30, 2024 9:09:08 GMT
Then why do you mention it? OP was asking for artillery generals that it could afford for around <2k medals. It is you who brought it up and veered the topic first, I mentioned ECs because you said Govorov is needed in the end anyway and I disagreed, all counter I made afterward is the continue of this topic. As for OP’s question, Sikorski will be the good deal he can use all the way to endgame, while Govorov will be expensive to just catch up everybody’s marching pace (cost +300 ~ +900 medals), and I see even an infantry-artillery build or tank-artillery build EC will be no less capable than Govorov in terms of endgame, let alone a dedicated artillery EC. How did I veered the topic? All I did is say the reasons between picking the artillery generals, and all of a sudden you brought up EC into the topic, which is unrelated to OP's question. |
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Jan 30, 2024 9:15:45 GMT
radomir000 EC is the xx commander you get for free. They are very expensive to upgrade, but also extremely powerful when well-developed. As an early game player, Govorov is a better fit for you but I would still recommend trying a bit harder for Guderian. Just One Bite resiphius Here's my thought on Sikorski vs Govorov: if you can freely pick the medals and the two NEVER move together, then Govorov's pros against artillery + assault Sikorski are only explosives and movement. However, we also need to take practicality into consideration. Sikorski, when equipped with 2 artillery medals, doesn't have a huge advantage against Govorov. Tank ECs have the top priority when it comes to assault medals and need them in large quantity, meaning it will take a very long time before Sikorski gets one, not to mention the air generals might want them as well. Artillery + combo Sikorski has no reason to split up with Govorov. As for artillery EC, I don't think it's as favorable as tank or infantry EC at endgame. I'll go begin saving now for a decent tank commander - what are the best options even on a budget? I have Sikorski, crerar and three unupgraded EC Guderian and Katukov. There's no third option. |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Jan 30, 2024 15:57:40 GMT
I'll go begin saving now for a decent tank commander - what are the best options even on a budget? I have Sikorski, crerar and three unupgraded EC Guderian and Katukov. There's no third option. Vatutin? He is ~1600 medals, 5* tanks and good skills |
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Jan 30, 2024 18:59:44 GMT
Guderian and Katukov. There's no third option. Vatutin? He is ~1600 medals, 5* tanks and good skills No. He's obsolete since long ago. You have enough tools to help you reach Guderian and Katukov. Do not get anyone else for now. |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Jan 30, 2024 19:08:58 GMT
Vatutin? He is ~1600 medals, 5* tanks and good skills No. He's obsolete since long ago. You have enough tools to help you reach Guderian and Katukov. Do not get anyone else for now. god saving for 3000+ medals is gonna get hard, especially when i cannot get ads working (says ad not ready) |
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Jan 30, 2024 19:48:52 GMT
No. He's obsolete since long ago. You have enough tools to help you reach Guderian and Katukov. Do not get anyone else for now. god saving for 3000+ medals is gonna get hard, especially when i cannot get ads working (says ad not ready) That's why I strongly encouraged to get Guderian first in my guide. |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Jan 30, 2024 20:03:12 GMT
guderian costs 3350 medals, there was no way ever i could have gotten him that early
|
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Jan 31, 2024 22:47:56 GMT
guderian costs 3350 medals, there was no way ever i could have gotten him that early It certainly is. It was hard before the new updates, but now that we have more medal rewards in early game, a good free air general, and much easier farming methods, straight to Guderian is doable even for beginners. Anyway. Your task right now is to get Guderian. No one should distract you besides Katukov. |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Feb 2, 2024 16:24:52 GMT
guderian costs 3350 medals, there was no way ever i could have gotten him that early It certainly is. It was hard before the new updates, but now that we have more medal rewards in early game, a good free air general, and much easier farming methods, straight to Guderian is doable even for beginners. Anyway. Your task right now is to get Guderian. No one should distract you besides Katukov. i have ~1500 medals, i am beginning to struggle in missions (i have 3 ecs, only upgraded to 35/50 health, otherwise bone stock and i have crerar, sikorski and sansonetti, all of which are not upgraded in health) |
|
