|
|
Post by radomir000 on Feb 3, 2024 17:30:36 GMT
is there a condensed sort of tier list where all the generals are colour coded according to how good they are (similar to EW4 tier list) and a reason or reasons why they are there
e.g Govorov (excellent) - Monstrous arty output for 1870 medals but rather slow (5* arty, lvl4 arty barrage, lvl3 plain fighting, lvl2 explosive, lvl2 arty leader)
Crerar (great) - Lvl 4 Plain Fighting allows him to dish out 5* output from tanks/infantry/artillery (despite his low stars) as long as he is in unmarked tiles
.....
Budyonny/Voroshilov/maybe Model (WORST GENERAL/S IN THE GAME!!!!!)
- Budyonny/Voroshilov have neither the stars nor the skill levels (though they are good skills, they are only lvl1)
- Model costs 3040 medals for meh high level skills (Defence Tactic, Fortification, Shelter Expert) and the actually decent skills are low level (Bayonet Charge, Street Fighting) but he does have ok stars, still doesn't save him from being the Blucher equivalent of WC3
Model is also a colonel for that price (ewwww, 140 hp)
|
|
|
|
Post by Jeanne d'Arc on Feb 3, 2024 22:51:49 GMT
While Erich von Manstein's list serves a similar job and Netherfreek's WC3 library colour-codes the generals by quality, I don't think anyone's combined general analysis and colour-coding, which is quite the shame, as such a tier list is needed with the ever-changing meta of this game.
(Maybe YOU could do it, you seem to have a knack for nice, snappy explanations as demonstrated here.)
|
|
|
|
Post by Just One Bite on Feb 4, 2024 1:46:55 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Feb 5, 2024 6:08:28 GMT
While Erich von Manstein's list serves a similar job and Netherfreek's WC3 library colour-codes the generals by quality, I don't think anyone's combined general analysis and colour-coding, which is quite the shame, as such a tier list is needed with the ever-changing meta of this game. (Maybe YOU could do it, you seem to have a knack for nice, snappy explanations as demonstrated here.) Honestly I don't see the need. EW4 has a lot of flexibility in choosing generals thanks to regrouping but WC3 doesn't, so all we need to do is list the ones worth getting. |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Feb 25, 2024 15:29:56 GMT
i could, only if I had time - I could indeed make a few separate comments in a thread, and ask people to refrain from commenting until tierlist finish
sorry for not replying, didnt pop up in notification
|
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Feb 25, 2024 15:31:03 GMT
While Erich von Manstein's list serves a similar job and Netherfreek's WC3 library colour-codes the generals by quality, I don't think anyone's combined general analysis and colour-coding, which is quite the shame, as such a tier list is needed with the ever-changing meta of this game. (Maybe YOU could do it, you seem to have a knack for nice, snappy explanations as demonstrated here.) yeah i could do that, itll take time tho |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Feb 25, 2024 15:32:13 GMT
While Erich von Manstein's list serves a similar job and Netherfreek's WC3 library colour-codes the generals by quality, I don't think anyone's combined general analysis and colour-coding, which is quite the shame, as such a tier list is needed with the ever-changing meta of this game. (Maybe YOU could do it, you seem to have a knack for nice, snappy explanations as demonstrated here.) Honestly I don't see the need. EW4 has a lot of flexibility in choosing generals thanks to regrouping but WC3 doesn't, so all we need to do is list the ones worth getting. Eh, might as well put in the bad generals in the tierlist so people don't ask when that general is not in the tierlist |
|
saga
First Lieutenant
Posts: 42
|
Post by saga on Mar 6, 2024 6:48:36 GMT
Honestly I don't see the need. EW4 has a lot of flexibility in choosing generals thanks to regrouping but WC3 doesn't, so all we need to do is list the ones worth getting. Eh, might as well put in the bad generals in the tierlist so people don't ask when that general is not in the tierlist Where is the other general like guderian, rommel, etc? You should add more to the list or like even the shop general like tolbulkin etc |
|
|
|
Post by radomir000 on Mar 7, 2024 20:10:27 GMT
Where is the other general like guderian, rommel, etc? You should add more to the list or like even the shop general like tolbulkin etc lol i havent created the damned tierlist yet am currently messing about with wanting a few generals added to wc3 (chiang kai shek, mao zedong, khorloogiin choibalsan (not shown in a post yet) and subhas chandra bose (not fully drawn up yet) |
|
