|
Post by NetherFreek on Nov 8, 2016 8:07:51 GMT
Okay, so i checked this forum and saw all these threads about those 3 above, vatutin, rommel and patton. Let's just compare them.
First things first, we all agree who's number 1, guderian. What are the weaknesses of guderian? City cracking and surviving. Who's capable of that? Yes, Patton is.
Total Avarage Output Guderian 55,1 1. Rommel 49,1 2. Vatutin 47,3 3. Patton 36,1
Output above 50 Guderian 49,6 1. Rommel 40,6 2. Patton 39,6 3. Vatutin 38,8
Output below 50 Guderian 60,6 1. Rommel 57,6 2. Vatutin 55,8 3. Patton 32,6
City cracking 1. Patton 63,6 Guderian 49,6 2. Rommel 39,6 3. Vatutin 38,8
Ability to regain lives 1. Patton 4 2. Rommel 4 3. Vatutin 2 Guderian 0
Land damage resistence Guderian 16 1. Patton 9 2. Rommel 0 3. Vatutin 0
Movement (through plains, armored car-tank-heavy tank-super tank) Guderian 5-4-4-4 1. Patton 5-4-4-3 2. Rommel 5-4-4-3 3. Vatutin 4-3-3-3
Air damage 1. Patton 16 Guderian 12 2. Rommel 12 3. Vatutin 0
Lives 1. Patton 200 2. Rommel 200 3. Guderian 170 4. Vatutin 120
Price 1. Vatutin 1630 2. Rommel 3300 3. Guderian 3350 4. Patton 3430
Conclusion.
Guderian is definitely #1. The second tank general we should buy should assist him in his weaknesses. How odd! Every time guderian is not #1 patton is! Patton fills in all the weaknesses from Guderian! Therefore Patton is the best assistent for Guderian. Whereass vatutin is a lite-version of him, Patton can actually contribute something new Vatutin can't.
Rommel can survive, yes, but patton can survive as well. Plus patton can defend as a beast.
|
|
|
Post by kanue on Nov 10, 2016 13:43:11 GMT
My choice for the second tank gen would be Patton for the reason you just mentioned... cracking city. tho, he lacks the sustainability (Tide of Iron).
|
|
|
Post by purtylee on Mar 10, 2018 4:05:01 GMT
3 cracks and his hp drops and then useless
|
|
|
Post by Gone on Dec 31, 2018 1:32:36 GMT
I know Patton is basically a waste of medals but Guderian only unlocks at HQ 14 and I am struggling to complete the WW2 Europe part with only Messe, and I am still HQ 10. Is there any way to level the HQ up other than completing the campaign?
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Dec 31, 2018 4:25:19 GMT
I know Patton is basically a waste of medals but Guderian only unlocks at HQ 14 and I am struggling to complete the WW2 Europe part with only Messe, and I am still HQ 10. Is there any way to level the HQ up other than completing the campaign? Conquests, challenges, missions, etc. And you are referring to WC4 right? If Patton is a waste in WC3, then probably Guderian and Govorov are the only two that aren’t wastes in the non-IAPs.
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich “Fried Rice” Paulus on Dec 31, 2018 4:34:13 GMT
I know Patton is basically a waste of medals but Guderian only unlocks at HQ 14 and I am struggling to complete the WW2 Europe part with only Messe, and I am still HQ 10. Is there any way to level the HQ up other than completing the campaign? Conquests, challenges, missions, etc. And you are referring to WC4 right? If Patton is a waste in WC3, then probably Guderian and Govorov are the only two that aren’t wastes in the non-IAPs. Even manstein himself isn’t immune to the lack of tide of iron, and he has lvl 3 plain fighting.
|
|