|
|
Post by Singlemalt on Dec 7, 2016 13:18:37 GMT
.org/image/7zf3vrpmv/]  [/url] .org/image/ftfph5xfr/]  [/url] since the update has arrived on ios and we can see the campaigns are really harsher too finish I think a new discussion can be started on 1. Are horse generals good at all, since their vulnerability against, archers who are running around a lot 2. If you say yes, which 1 would be better. Taken in account the limited amount of medals and their weakness against archers my thoughts for now: 1. Yes, but probably 1 horse general, with maximal survivability? |
|
|
|
Post by kanue on Dec 8, 2016 4:40:41 GMT
I haven't tried the new content so I cant say much about campaign but, in my opinion, Saladin is better for conquest because he can always be at full health with his logistic skill. Though, in campaign where I hear a lot of archer and tercio, I doubt if he can contribute much.
|
|
|
|
Post by burningwings on Dec 8, 2016 18:04:56 GMT
Here is my opinion: 1. They will be good at getting 3 star in campaign if they are strong enough because they can kill many units in one round.  2. Saladin for conquest and Attila for campaign, but I will only go for Attila upgrade anyone else and get all Gold Items. I think there will be another golden Cav-Gen by that time. In my case, I upgrade Suleiman only because I think he is better than both. He is also faster with Movement=9. |
|
|
|
Post by Singlemalt on Dec 8, 2016 18:09:22 GMT
Here is my opinion: 1. They will be good at getting 3 star in campaign if they are strong enough because they can kill many units in one round. 2. Saladin for conquest and Attila for campaign, but I will only go for Attila upgrade anyone else and get all Gold Items. I think there will be another golden Cav-Gen by that time. In my case, I upgrade Suleiman only because I think he is better than both. He is also faster with Movement=9. I added him in the title.. why do you prefer suleiman? Due to his health? |
|
|
|
Post by burningwings on Dec 8, 2016 18:24:30 GMT
Mine is only 30 so I will upload my Suleiman and Saladin.   70 Hp is not really big. 30 Atk isn't as much as Attack Master, but 20 Def and Defense Master make him survival longer in Campaign. Higher Movement speed. Rumor is also good skill after upgraded. His skill set is only worse than the IAP Ghengis at the moment. That is the reason I pick him. The down side is he cost 3000 Medals. But I won't regret spending on him. |
|
|
|
Post by Tariq ibn Ziyad on Dec 12, 2016 1:19:10 GMT
So, Sulaiman > Salahuddin > Attila (?)
|
|
|
|
Post by best75 on Dec 12, 2016 1:54:51 GMT
Attila has braveness which i consider a very good skill in campaign because it allows you to hit powerful enemy generals without getting hit back. Combined that with his high attack makes him very good for destroying enemy units and generals.
A big reason I have Saladin is because you can get him for no medals. If saladin costs medals instead i might had gone with allita.
|
|
|
|
Post by Singlemalt on Dec 12, 2016 7:04:59 GMT
It is still not defenite I would concluede.
Atilla will not get hit by strong enemies but the vulnarebility of horse generals against archers is hugh.. there are lots of strong archers everywhere around so regaining health will probably be important too..
Logistics by saladin can help in this. But probably the 4 items the cavalery general will wear can also be sufficient
|
|
|
|
Post by Imperial RomeBall on Dec 25, 2016 20:36:02 GMT
huh. I am on the Carolingian campaign, and my only (frontline) cavalry general is Hannibal with level 5 braveness (off and on, but the max level if attained is constant) and almost no other upgrades. Are these 3 the only 3rd tier Cavalry generals? I want to leave hannibal as a war elephant, since he looks best that way  Id get Attila, but he probably costs a lot of medals to upgrade to 4th level. BTW, if Cavalry generals really suck so much in later campaigns, why not only keep one in your lineup? Then the rest will be artillery archery or infantry. |
|
|
|
Post by odm on Dec 25, 2016 21:07:35 GMT
Attila starts from 1st tier and also you can upgrade purple to 4 stars for 600 medals. As for "are these only", there are also Bătu Khan, Henry, El Fie ( Grey) and Asoka, Hannibal and Huo Oubling ( blues) and also Charlemagne, which is not compared since he is not gold he does not have the right skills.(Shelter is really bar and Assault Expert does not help)
|
|
|
|
Post by Imperial RomeBall on Dec 25, 2016 23:14:00 GMT
Attila starts from 1st tier and also you can upgrade purple to 4 stars for 600 medals. As for "are these only", there are also Bătu Khan, Henry, El Fie ( Grey) and Asoka, Hannibal and Huo Oubling ( blues) and also Charlemagne, which is not compared since he is not gold he does not have the right skills.(Shelter is really bar and Assault Expert does not help) When I said 3rd tier I meant purple and gold generals. I too, noticed that Charlemagne is too weak. sad, since he is the only purplish-gold general for those who want semi-modern european generals. I think I am going to get and use Atilla, and upgrade his braveness perhaps. I'm like 5 medals away. I guess that is a total waste when I could get Saladin, but whatever. His stats seem slightly worse in that photo, but at least he seems to have a higher attack boost skill. Thanks, but I needed no list of blue-grays since I have hannibal already. good for anyone else reading I guess. I assume El fie, is El cid. Now, to go and seduce Lincoln |
|
|
|
Post by best75 on Dec 25, 2016 23:31:02 GMT
Attila starts from 1st tier and also you can upgrade purple to 4 stars for 600 medals. As for "are these only", there are also Bătu Khan, Henry, El Fie ( Grey) and Asoka, Hannibal and Huo Oubling ( blues) and also Charlemagne, which is not compared since he is not gold he does not have the right skills.(Shelter is really bar and Assault Expert does not help) When I said 3rd tier I meant purple and gold generals. I too, noticed that Charlemagne is too weak. sad, since he is the only purplish-gold general for those who want semi-modern european generals. I think I am going to get and use Atilla, and upgrade his braveness perhaps. I'm like 5 medals away. I guess that is a total waste when I could get Saladin, but whatever. His stats seem slightly worse in that photo, but at least he seems to have a higher attack boost skill. Thanks, but I needed no list of blue-grays since I have hannibal already. good for anyone else reading I guess. I assume El fie, is El cid. Now, to go and seduce Lincoln 3rd tier general blucher. He is unlocked in gunpowder age. He is quite defensive due to his skills. .org/image/ej65tevp3/]  [/url] |
|
|
|
Post by Imperial RomeBall on Dec 25, 2016 23:50:08 GMT
Huh, he seems to have weaker health, plus a higher price than Suleiman. Great, now I have to budget:Blucher or Bismarck (I assume he IS in this game?)
My line-up right now is Nobunaga, Alexander, Hannibal (will stay with his elephant bros), Catherine, Barbarossa (teutonic order, and no further) Cleopatra and mebbe robin hood. As you can tell from the list, I need a replacement for Hannibal but especially for Cleopatra, who now does no more damage against forts than most of my team. Instead of getting Li shimin I might wait for Bismarck.
|
|
|
|
Post by best75 on Dec 26, 2016 1:08:54 GMT
Huh, he seems to have weaker health, plus a higher price than Suleiman. Great, now I have to budget:Blucher or Bismarck (I assume he IS in this game?) My line-up right now is Nobunaga, Alexander, Hannibal (will stay with his elephant bros), Catherine, Barbarossa (teutonic order, and no further) Cleopatra and mebbe robin hood. As you can tell from the list, I need a replacement for Hannibal but especially for Cleopatra, who now does no more damage against forts than most of my team. Instead of getting Li shimin I might wait for Bismarck. Bismarck will unlock in the Industrial Age which is last age on the game. That will be long wait and a good artillery general is quite important. |
|
|
|
Post by Imperial RomeBall on Dec 26, 2016 1:27:52 GMT
I see. I'm not really sure I want Li-shimin (very likely the best), and Koxinga is only slightly more unique, yet also weaker. (well, you could argue he is much more unique, but I dunno)
This is getting off-topic, but I'd be interested to know If there are any artillery generals that unlock in Gunpowder, since I'm in Discovery. Guess its koxinga or Shimin at this point.
I wonder how you guys would rank them? Blucher-Suleiman-Atilla-Saladin.
|
|
