|
|
Post by Captain on Aug 22, 2021 12:31:10 GMT
1.Manstein 2.Zhukov 3.Kuribayashi 4.Donits 5.Yamamoto Kuribyashi? I think infantry generals are useless here. Though it's very necessary then Rundstedt, Yamashita, Mannerheim are there. |
|
|
|
Post by George Rudi on Aug 22, 2021 13:55:58 GMT
I think Yamamoto might be better than Donitz if given the fleet leader and rumour skill, cause. he also possesses the air advantage while Donitz is only best in naval. It's not apple to apple comparing Yamamoto and Donitz in term of air gen, because Donitz is pure Naval gen, while Yamamoto is the best Air (tied with Arnold) and Air/Naval hybrid. There's so much factor to decide which gens are considered worth to buy/ viable (best gen only belong to one and only Guderian), and Yamamoto isn't ranked in top 10 gens worth to buy. |
|
|
|
Post by Kliment Jefremovitš Vorošilov on Aug 22, 2021 16:43:24 GMT
Manstein and Zhukov are too expensive (costs real money). for mine it's: 1. Guderian (best of all time) 2. Konev (my comrade) 3. Nimitz (Best Pacific General) 4. Rokossovsky (a.k.a. me  )/ Rommel (the Desert Fox) 5. Donitz (best submarine general) I think Yamamoto might be better than Donitz if given the fleet leader and rumour skill, cause. he also possesses the air advantage while Donitz is only best in naval. For me air generals are only useful in some domination levels and speed running (which I am not doing), and Yamamoto can't have many necessary navy skills especially wolfpack which is crucial for invasions and other domination levels. One of the biggest reasons that make Dönitz so great is that level 4 wolfpack which makes other ships hit like they had a general on. Also Yamamoto can't have Sailor, Depot ship nor Explosives either. |
|
|
|
Post by George Rudi on Aug 22, 2021 17:19:26 GMT
For me air generals are only useful in some domination levels and speed running (which I am not doing), and Yamamoto can't have many necessary navy skills especially wolfpack which is crucial for invasions and other domination levels. One of the biggest reasons that make Dönitz so great is that level 4 wolfpack which makes other ships hit like they had a general on. Also Yamamoto can't have Sailor, Depot ship nor Explosives either. lol, Yamamoto already has explosive, and yes, he can have sailor/rumor and fleet leader. Depot ship? worse than machinist for a Naval gen. He's the best carrier/super carrier gen |
|
|
|
Post by Kliment Jefremovitš Vorošilov on Aug 22, 2021 17:31:37 GMT
For me air generals are only useful in some domination levels and speed running (which I am not doing), and Yamamoto can't have many necessary navy skills especially wolfpack which is crucial for invasions and other domination levels. One of the biggest reasons that make Dönitz so great is that level 4 wolfpack which makes other ships hit like they had a general on. Also Yamamoto can't have Sailor, Depot ship nor Explosives either. lol, Yamamoto already has explosive, and yes, he can have sailor/rumor and fleet leader. Depot ship? worse than machinist for a Naval gen. He's the best carrier/super carrier gen Oh yeah, he has Explosives . Yeah, agree on that one but for a navy gen wolfpack is crucial. |
|
|
|
Post by George Rudi on Aug 22, 2021 17:47:41 GMT
Oh yeah, he has Explosives . Yeah, agree on that one but for a navy gen wolfpack is crucial. for invasion, yes, wolfpack helps a lot, but in campaign or conquest for no-good economic country (which almost impossible to build navy spam), wolfpack is less useful than explosive or sailor |
|
|
|
Post by Kliment Jefremovitš Vorošilov on Aug 22, 2021 17:53:17 GMT
Oh yeah, he has Explosives . Yeah, agree on that one but for a navy gen wolfpack is crucial. for invasion, yes, wolfpack helps a lot, but in campaign or conquest for no-good economic country (which almost impossible to build navy spam), wolfpack is less useful than explosive or sailor In campaign you usually start with a good amount of units and in conquest navy isn't that important. |
|
|
|
Post by journeykeen on Aug 22, 2021 18:18:56 GMT
for invasion, yes, wolfpack helps a lot, but in campaign or conquest for no-good economic country (which almost impossible to build navy spam), wolfpack is less useful than explosive or sailor In campaign you usually start with a good amount of units and in conquest navy isn't that important. A navy general with explosives can, with paratrooper help, near single-handedly kill Japan in something like 39’ or 43’ conquest. A cruiser is just as dominant in the Mediterranean. |
|
|
|
Post by Kliment Jefremovitš Vorošilov on Aug 22, 2021 18:31:52 GMT
In campaign you usually start with a good amount of units and in conquest navy isn't that important. A navy general with explosives can, with paratrooper help, near single-handedly kill Japan in something like 39’ or 43’ conquest. A cruiser is just as dominant in the Mediterranean. But a navy general almost never changes the outcome of a conquest only makes it faster. |
|
|
|
Post by Manfred von Richthofen on Aug 23, 2021 0:00:05 GMT
Manstein and Zhukov are too expensive (costs real money). for mine it's: 1. Guderian (best of all time) 2. Konev (my comrade) 3. Nimitz (Best Pacific General) 4. Rokossovsky (a.k.a. me )/ Rommel (the Desert Fox) 5. Donitz (best submarine general) I think Yamamoto might be better than Donitz if given the fleet leader and rumour skill, cause. he also possesses the air advantage while Donitz is only best in naval. if you want an air general, get Dowding or Arnold. I had Yamamoto before i got Nimitz and he was trash. So i sold him and got Nimitz. skills for Dowding: Industrial/Tech Expert. For Arnold get Crossfire or Cover |
|
|
|
Post by journeykeen on Aug 23, 2021 3:26:20 GMT
A navy general with explosives can, with paratrooper help, near single-handedly kill Japan in something like 39’ or 43’ conquest. A cruiser is just as dominant in the Mediterranean. But a navy general almost never changes the outcome of a conquest only makes it faster. I mean… there’s very few conquests where the eventual outcome is uncertain. |
|
|
|
Post by Captain on Aug 23, 2021 13:33:13 GMT
I think Yamamoto might be better than Donitz if given the fleet leader and rumour skill, cause. he also possesses the air advantage while Donitz is only best in naval. if you want an air general, get Dowding or Arnold. I had Yamamoto before i got Nimitz and he was trash. So i sold him and got Nimitz. skills for Dowding: Industrial/Tech Expert. For Arnold get Crossfire or Cover Yeah and apologizes for any misunderstanding😅😅 actually I had bought Yamamoto previously and want to know- what other players recommend! Still he is very costly that's why I posted such,before taking any action... |
|
|
|
Post by Captain on Aug 23, 2021 13:35:07 GMT
I think Yamamoto might be better than Donitz if given the fleet leader and rumour skill, cause. he also possesses the air advantage while Donitz is only best in naval. if you want an air general, get Dowding or Arnold. I had Yamamoto before i got Nimitz and he was trash. So i sold him and got Nimitz. skills for Dowding: Industrial/Tech Expert. For Arnold get Crossfire or Cover Thanks for the recommendation 😃😃👍👍 |
|
|
|
Post by Captain on Aug 23, 2021 14:10:31 GMT
I think Yamamoto might be better than Donitz if given the fleet leader and rumour skill, cause. he also possesses the air advantage while Donitz is only best in naval. For me air generals are only useful in some domination levels and speed running (which I am not doing), and Yamamoto can't have many necessary navy skills especially wolfpack which is crucial for invasions and other domination levels. One of the biggest reasons that make Dönitz so great is that level 4 wolfpack which makes other ships hit like they had a general on. Also Yamamoto can't have Sailor, Depot ship nor Explosives either. Dear Vorosilov, actually I am not keeping Yamamoto greater than Donitz. I just keep Yamamoto better only in respect for completing whole scenario as fast it can be and for me Donitz seem to be more expensive that's why I said so!! |
|
|
|
Post by Kliment Jefremovitš Vorošilov on Aug 23, 2021 14:39:54 GMT
For me air generals are only useful in some domination levels and speed running (which I am not doing), and Yamamoto can't have many necessary navy skills especially wolfpack which is crucial for invasions and other domination levels. One of the biggest reasons that make Dönitz so great is that level 4 wolfpack which makes other ships hit like they had a general on. Also Yamamoto can't have Sailor, Depot ship nor Explosives either. Dear Vorosilov, actually I am not keeping Yamamoto greater than Donitz. I just keep Yamamoto better only in respect for completing whole scenario as fast it can be and for me Donitz seem to be more expensive that's why I said so!! Yeah, overall Yamamoto is great but a bit pricey. |
|
)/ Rommel (the Desert Fox)
