|
|
Post by Darth Vader on May 24, 2020 4:02:30 GMT
Don't think many people will even think about replacing Guderian. The way I would replace gudarian is if all me slots have excellent generals and i get Manstien instead for free along with 1,000 medals. |
|
|
|
Post by Harry Lillis "Bing" Crosby Jr on May 25, 2020 13:39:00 GMT
Don't think many people will even think about replacing Guderian. The way I would replace gudarian is if all me slots have excellent generals and i get Manstien instead for free along with 1,000 medals. Why IAP though  Isn't manstein an IAP? Or you can get him for free in wc3? |
|
|
|
Post by Darth Vader on May 25, 2020 14:24:35 GMT
Why IAP though Isn't manstein an IAP? Or you can get him for free in wc3? No he is expensive, just wish there was a event to achieve him. |
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich āFried Riceā Paulus on Jun 7, 2020 19:19:06 GMT
Why IAP though Ā Isn't manstein an IAP? Or you can get him for free in wc3? He is an iap artillery generals (he looks like a tank general but is way better on artillery). |
|
|
|
Post by Harry Lillis "Bing" Crosby Jr on Jun 8, 2020 8:54:58 GMT
What a turn of events... but surely looking at how useful ECs are in wc3, and that Bai/Govorov and gang are leading the pack, he's not going to be too popular
|
|
|
|
Post by Friedrich āFried Riceā Paulus on Jun 8, 2020 16:50:54 GMT
What a turn of events... but surely looking at how useful ECs are in wc3, and that Bai/Govorov and gang are leading the pack, he's not going to be too popular Nah he is pretty good. Heās has stand out movement on artillery being the only general that has 5 stars movement on artillery, or at least do that and still be good. He is Bai with an extra movement star, lvl 4 explosives, an extra plain level, and an extra artillery star so he is actually significantly better than bai. Bai does have artillery barrage whereas manstein lacks tide of iron, making him a meh tanker. Mansteinās hits harder than Govorov against cities as well. Mansteinās output is slightly worse than govorov, of course the main flaw being the lack of tide of iron/artillery barrage. Manstein is also really good on a super tank, especially when there are no rockets/nukes around nearby, such as when invading the ussr. He is actually 20$ here though, not 12$ so he like Eisenhower and Zhukov are all very expensive. |
|
|
|
Post by Harry Lillis "Bing" Crosby Jr on Jun 9, 2020 7:51:39 GMT
What a turn of events... but surely looking at how useful ECs are in wc3, and that Bai/Govorov and gang are leading the pack, he's not going to be too popular Nah he is pretty good. Heās has stand out movement on artillery being the only general that has 5 stars movement on artillery, or at least do that and still be good. He is Bai with an extra movement star, lvl 4 explosives, an extra plain level, and an extra artillery star so he is actually significantly better than bai. Bai does have artillery barrage whereas manstein lacks tide of iron, making him a meh tanker. Mansteinās hits harder than Govorov against cities as well. Mansteinās output is slightly worse than govorov, of course the main flaw being the lack of tide of iron/artillery barrage. Manstein is also really good on a super tank, especially when there are no rockets/nukes around nearby, such as when invading the ussr. He is actually 20$ here though, not 12$ so he like Eisenhower and Zhukov are all very expensive. hence he's the second best artillery general in the game? |
|
|
|
Post by Erich von Manstein on Jun 18, 2020 23:46:31 GMT
Nah he is pretty good. Heās has stand out movement on artillery being the only general that has 5 stars movement on artillery, or at least do that and still be good. He is Bai with an extra movement star, lvl 4 explosives, an extra plain level, and an extra artillery star so he is actually significantly better than bai. Bai does have artillery barrage whereas manstein lacks tide of iron, making him a meh tanker. Mansteinās hits harder than Govorov against cities as well. Mansteinās output is slightly worse than govorov, of course the main flaw being the lack of tide of iron/artillery barrage. Manstein is also really good on a super tank, especially when there are no rockets/nukes around nearby, such as when invading the ussr. He is actually 20$ here though, not 12$ so he like Eisenhower and Zhukov are all very expensive. hence he's the second best artillery general in the game? Arguably the best. No one can reject a fast powerful artillery. Strictly speaking Manstein on tank is stronger than him on artillery (ofc look at his stats), but Patton can do a pretty ok job at what Manstein on tank mainly does, whereas Bai is not even close to Manstein. |
|
|
|
Post by Harry Lillis "Bing" Crosby Jr on Jun 19, 2020 9:31:46 GMT
hence he's the second best artillery general in the game? Arguably the best. No one can reject a fast powerful artillery. Strictly speaking Manstein on tank is better stronger him on artillery (ofc look at his stats), but Patton can do a pretty ok job at what Manstein on tank mainly does, where as Bai is not even close to Manstein. I see, other than Sevastopol I dont see where Manstein has distinguished himself in artillery use IRL haha. Perhaps I'll get answers from reading Verlorene Siege, which I just bought with eased COVID restrictions. Costly(as expected from gen autobios), but hopefully rewarding  |
|
Isn't manstein an IAP? Or you can get him for free in wc3?
