Respond from the Chinese players.

It's the next I need to say. I will tell you how to count the dmg. But it's really hard for me. So many words I don't know how to say. I hope google translate can help me.
First, you need to know the dmg depend on the maxatk. For example, during Suvorov to light infantry of fra(5-7,single line), and Victoria to line infantry of fra(1-7,single line,infantry 5 stars), the max dmg and the average dmg are all the same. The max dmg is 7*5+5*5=60, the average is 60/2=30. Increasing the maxatk will increase the dmg. Increasing the minatk will only increase 1 to the min dmg.
I called the dmg from army "board dmg", and dmg from general "general dmg". The total dmg is "board dmg"+"general dmg".The max dmg of light infantry is 30, it belong to "board dmg". Infantry 5 stars, take Ferguson Rifle, this belong to "general dmg". I will explain how to count the "board dmg" and the total dmg.
If the minatk is "a",the maxatk is "b", the max dmg is c*b, c=5(single line),6(double),7(triple). The computer will randomly select 2 number between 1 and b*c, add these 2 numbers,then divided by 2,now get the theoretical dmg(rounddown). Then add the theoretical dmg to "general dmg",if the total is less than "a",the total dmg is "a".If the total is more than "a", the total dmg is the theoretical dmg add "general dmg". Because every star cost 5 dmg, so if the general has more than 1 star, usually the total will be more than "a". Then you can see, the minatk is useless to most of generals. The more the maxatk, the more the dmg.
I need to go to sleep. I will explain the rest in next a few days.

There are always some players with good skill in the forum, that is what they ususlly do, all kinds of testing and game strategies!

Erich von Manstein we have players with good skills in here as well.The only difference in this community is that we have maybe 40-50 members playing European war 4 while you have 15,000 members or more playing EU4 on your board.Our forum is fairly new but we are growing!
So yeah,chances are the base knowledge is higher on the other side and it should be.
Understand,I don't think people are challenging you or your friends, or refusing to acknowledge your information just to be rigid or selfish. On the contrary most of us love new information and new ways of thinking even if it proves we have not been entirely accurate in the past.

we just want to see the raw data whenever possible.If it's not available or lost then fine you can say so,it's not a big deal,but if it is available we would love to see it.

Chinese Player I don't know if this is just one player or several but thanks for sharing and looking forward to hearing more.Your English is perfectly understandable  and mathematics is a universal language

I don't know how to share my test to you. If you have email, I can send to you.

Single line
1-2（Suvorov） 1-2 2-3（Suvorov） 2-3 3-4（Suvorov） 10-11（Suvorov） 10-11 10-11（Moreau,infantry 5 stars）
26 1 1 1 27 2 27 1 29 10 33
27 2 27 2 28 1 29 10 36
27 2 27 3 2 3 29 33 10 37
27 3 2 3 28 4 29 2 34 10 38
28 3 28 4 30 34 10 38
28 3 28 4 30 36 10 39
28 3 28 4 30 37 10 39
28 3 28 4 30 4 37 11 39
28 3 28 6 4 31 37 11 40
28 3 29 4 31 37 12 41
28 3 29 4 31 38 14 41
28 3 29 4 31 38 14 41
28 3 29 4 10 31 38 15 42
28 10 3 10 29 5 31 6 39 15 43
29 4 29 5 32 39 15 43
29 4 29 5 32 39 15 43
29 4 29 5 32 41 15 44
29 4 29 9 5 32 41 15 44
29 4 30 5 32 41 17 44
29 4 30 5 32 41 17 45
29 4 30 5 32 42 17 46
29 4 30 5 32 42 18 46
29 4 30 5 10 32 9 43 18 46
29 4 30 6 33 43 18 46
29 4 30 6 33 43 18 46
29 4 30 6 33 43 19 46
29 4 30 9 6 33 43 19 47
29 4 31 6 33 43 19 47
29 4 31 6 33 43 19 47
29 16 4 16 31 6 33 44 20 48
30 5 31 6 33 44 20 49
30 5 31 6 33 9 44 20 49
30 5 31 6 34 44 20 49
30 5 31 6 34 44 20 49
30 5 31 6 12 34 45 21 49
30 5 31 7 34 45 21 49
30 5 31 7 34 45 21 50
30 5 31 7 34 45 21 50
30 5 31 7 34 45 21 50
30 5 31 7 34 45 22 50
30 5 31 7 34 46 22 50
30 5 31 15 7 34 46 22 50
30 5 32 7 34 46 22 51
30 5 32 7 34 46 22 51
30 5 32 7 34 47 22 51
30 5 32 7 34 47 22 51
30 5 32 7 34 15 47 22 52
30 5 32 7 35 47 22 52
30 5 32 7 35 47 22 52
30 20 5 20 32 7 35 47 22 52
31 6 32 7 35 47 23 52
31 6 32 7 35 47 23 52
31 6 32 7 35 47 23 53
31 6 32 7 35 47 23 53
31 6 32 7 35 47 23 53
31 6 32 14 7 35 47 23 53
31 6 33 7 22 35 47 24 53
31 6 33 8 35 47 24 54
31 6 33 8 35 47 24 54
31 6 33 8 35 47 24 54
31 6 33 8 35 14 47 24 54
31 6 33 8 36 48 24 54
31 6 33 8 36 48 24 55
31 6 33 8 36 48 24 55
31 6 33 8 36 49 24 56
31 6 33 8 36 49 24 56
31 6 33 8 36 49 24 57
31 6 33 8 11 36 49 24 57
31 6 33 9 36 49 25 57
31 6 33 9 36 9 49 25 57
31 21 6 33 9 37 49 25 58
32 6 22 33 9 37 50 25 58
32 7 33 9 37 50 25 58
32 7 33 18 9 37 50 25 58
32 7 34 9 37 50 25 58
32 7 34 9 37 50 25 59
32 7 34 9 37 50 25 59
32 7 34 9 37 50 25 59
32 7 34 9 37 50 25 60
32 7 34 9 12 37 10 50 25 60
32 7 34 7 10 38 50 25 60
32 7 35 10 38 51 26 61
32 7 35 10 38 51 26 62
32 7 35 10 38 51 26 62
32 14 7 35 10 38 51 26 62
33 7 35 10 38 6 51 26 62
33 7 15 35 6 10 7 39 51 26 62
33 8 36 11 39 51 26 62
33 8 36 11 39 51 26 63
33 8 36 11 39 52 26 63
33 8 36 11 39 5 52 26 63
33 8 36 11 40 52 26 64
33 8 36 11 40 52 27 64
33 8 36 11 40 3 52 27 64
33 8 36 8 11 41 53 27 64
33 11 8 9 37 11 9 41 53 27 65
34 9 37 12 41 53 27 66
34 9 37 3 12 41 4 54 28 66
34 9 3 38 1 12 42 54 28 67
34 4 10 1 40 1 12 4 42 2 54 28 68
3049 100 547 100 3212 100 735 100 3489 100 54 28 5227
average 5.49 5.47 7.12 7.35 9.89 54 28 27.27
board 54 28
dmg 54 28
55 28
55 29
55 29
55 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 29
56 30
56 30
56 30
56 30
56 30
56 30
57 30
57 30
57 30
58 30
58 30
58 30
58 30
58 31
58 31
59 31
59 31
59 31
59 31
59 32
59 32
59 32
59 32
60 32
60 32
60 32
60 32
60 32
60 32
60 33
60 33
60 33
60 33
61 33
61 33
61 33
61 33
61 33
61 33
62 34
62 34
62 34
62 34
62 35
62 35
62 35
62 35
63 35
63 35
63 35
63 36
63 36
63 37
63 37
63 37
63 37
63 37
63 37
63 38
64 38
64 38
64 38
64 38
64 38
64 39
64 39
65 39
65 40
65 40
65 40
66 40
66 40
66 42
66 42
66 43
67 43
67 44
67 44
67 45
69 45
69 45
10613 5509
28.065 27.545

Can you tell me your email? I can send my test to you.

Here is the file.

The result is from changing the maximum and minimum damage of the army unit, so it shows the results more effective. The testing unit is militia, attacking heavy artillery with no level. The map is tested that it does not have hidden evasion. So the results could show the "board output" correctly.